The Witch of Pungo Was Thrown in a River in 1706 and Pardoned 300 Years Later
The logic of a ducking trial is that there is no correct answer. Throw the accused in the water bound hand to foot. If she sinks she is innocent, and also probably drowning. If she floats, the water has rejected her and she is a witch. On July 10, 1706, a widow named Grace Sherwood went into a branch of the Lynnhaven River in what is now Virginia Beach. She floated. What happened next is the part most retellings skip. She did not burn and she did not hang. The famous Witch of Pungo went to jail, got out, took her farm back through the courts, and lived to about 80 on her own land. Three hundred years to the day after the ducking, Virginia pardoned her.