A PLUS MINI MARKET★3.60.49 miOpen 24 hours128 N MAIN ST, New City, NY 10956Unleaded$4.50Midgrade$5.70Premium$6.00Diesel—Directions(845)634-0150WebsiteSafety: safe (97)
Gulf New City★3.50.61 miOpen · Closes 12 AMCheapest233 S MAIN ST, New City, NY 10956Unleaded$3.88Midgrade$4.38Premium$4.78Diesel—Directions(845)634-2050Safety: low risk (94)
SHELL★3.60.64 miOpen 24 hours255 S MAIN ST, New City, NY 10956Unleaded$4.10Midgrade$5.00Premium$5.40Diesel$6.50Directions(845)639-9833WebsiteSafety: low risk (94)