A Study Distributed $7,500 to Homeless People. The Results Are Challenging Our Biases

Photo byfreepik.com

In a groundbreaking study published just last week, the Foundations for Social Change, in collaboration with the University of British Columbia, embarked on a unique experiment in Vancouver, Canada.

They selected 50 individuals who had recently faced homelessness and presented each of them with a generous gift of $7,500. The catch? There were no strings attached. It was unconditional.

Ray, one of the beneficiaries, recalled his disbelief. After setting up a bank account with the help of a program representative, it took him a week to truly grasp the reality of his newfound fortune.

Over the subsequent year, researchers keenly observed how these individuals utilized their funds, contrasting their experiences with a control group of 65 homeless individuals who did not receive the financial boost. Both groups, however, were provided with life skills workshops and coaching.

The study also handed out a separate survey posing a question to the public: How would you expect someone, especially someone homeless, to spend a sudden windfall of $7,500? The majority anticipated a significant increase in expenditure on vices like alcohol, drugs, and tobacco.

But the actual results were hearteningly different. The beneficiaries primarily allocated their funds towards essentials like food, clothing, and rent. Many even secured stable housing swiftly, ensuring they had a financial safety net for the upcoming year.

Claire Williams, the driving force behind Foundations for Social Change, was impressed by the prudence displayed by the recipients. This study challenges the often-held belief that poverty is a result of poor decision-making or lack of self-control. In fact, research has consistently debunked the myth that financial aid leads to increased consumption of non-essentials.

Gary Bloch, a physician with years of experience working with the homeless, wasn't surprised by these findings. He emphasized that providing financial assistance to those in dire straits invariably yields positive outcomes, as evidenced by similar programs worldwide.

Moreover, this initiative proved to be economically savvy. By facilitating faster transitions into stable housing for 50 individuals, the shelter system saved an impressive $413,850 over a year. This amount surpassed the total disbursed, making the project not just compassionate but also cost-effective.

To further debunk misconceptions, the research team highlighted the societal savings and responsible spending habits of the homeless, effectively challenging prevailing stereotypes.

The inspiration for this project, dubbed the New Leaf Project, stemmed from a TED talk advocating for universal basic income. While the concept of providing a monthly stipend to all citizens has gained traction globally, Williams and her team opted for a one-time substantial amount. Their rationale? A significant sum can catalyze long-term planning, allowing individuals to break free from the shackles of day-to-day survival.

Ray's story stands testament to this belief. With his newfound resources, he pursued courses that enabled him to assist others battling addiction, transforming his life and giving back to the community.

However, the study had its constraints. It targeted individuals who had been homeless for a short duration and excluded those with severe mental health or addiction issues.

The future looks promising. The team aims to replicate this study on a grander scale, expanding to other cities and demographics, including ex-prisoners and individuals transitioning out of sex work. They also plan to enhance the support system by providing beneficiaries with tools like smartphones.

However, while cash injections are beneficial, they aren't the panacea for homelessness. As Bloch rightly points out, the ultimate solution lies in affordable housing and long-term financial security. But if this study manages to shatter some deep-rooted misconceptions about the homeless, it's a step in the right direction.