'Can't set bond with an Ouija board': Judge talks on bond anxiety in Nashville

Those with violent pasts can go back and sometimes commit other violent crimes in Nashville.

You've heard the frustration from Metro's police chief who says judges need to do better. Now a prominent local judge responds saying they are well aware of the problem.

"I would say the system overall continues to fail people. Once we arrest them and they are back out, that's a problem," said Metro Nashville Police Chief John Drake.

He thinks part of the issue is how judges set bonds.

"I understand the frustration, and I understand the optics of seeing people on bond allegedly committing new crimes, but we can't set bond with a Ouija board," said General Session Judge Jim Todd.

He said state statutes set the guidelines for bond, and everyone — except those in capital cases — is entitled to one.

"When you say he is violent and shouldn't get out again, you just adjudicated him and found him guilty. He did it. No trial. Bond $1 million. You see the problem there?" Judge Todd said.

But Todd concedes there needs to be changes.

First, he says Metro judges currently do not have access to an FBI database to see if someone arrested in Davidson County has a record of violent crimes elsewhere — a factor that could influence bond.

And, he says judges need to be able to set conditions on bonds — like curfew or no possession of weapons.

A violation would send a suspect back to jail.

"The public needs to know the courts are well aware of the issue and will work hard to maintain public safety on people who have a constitutional right to bond."

Judge Todd said he and others on the bench said they will work with the police chief, sheriff and the mayor's office to address the bond issue.

Carrie recommends:

Growing your family, no matter the journey to get there, is an emotional one. My heart aches for these families who trusted a Nashville fertility clinic with their dreams and finances. Hannah McDonald's relentlessness to find answers is journalism at its best and hopefully a new avenue of hope for the patients caught up in this mess.

-Carrie Sharp