KWIK FILL #80★4.00.29 miOpen 24 hoursCheapest14 WATER ST, Mayville, NY 14757Unleaded$4.40Midgrade$4.96Premium$5.40Diesel—Directions(716)753-3653WebsiteSafety: safe (100)
CROSBYS #45★3.61.06 miOpen · Closes 11 PM14 N ERIE ST, Mayville, NY 14757Unleaded$4.46Midgrade$4.96Premium$5.36Diesel$6.50Directions(716)219-5392WebsiteSafety: safe (96)
CROSBYS HARTFIELD★4.42.02 miOpen · Closes 11 PM6086 E LAKE RD, Mayville, NY 14757Unleaded$4.40Midgrade$4.96Premium$5.36Diesel$6.40Directions(716)219-5529WebsiteSafety: safe (98)