Taste the Spirit of '76 at America's oldest restaurant

In Tappan, history isn't just remembered - it's served.

The '76 House, widely recognized as America's oldest tavern, has been welcoming guests since 1686.

Today, owner Robert Norden - who prefers the title "tavernkeeper" - has spent more than 40 years preserving and sharing its remarkable past.

"A tavernkeeper is here looking over everything, making sure the customers' experience is as it should be," Norden said.

Step inside, and nearly every corner tells a story. The tavern is steeped in Revolutionary War history, including a moment tied to George Washington himself.

According to Norden, Washington once received plans at the tavern that exposed Benedict Arnold as a traitor - prompting a dramatic reaction still talked about today.

The site also played a role in the fate of British spy John André, who was imprisoned and later executed just outside the tavern.

But beyond its deep historical roots, the '76 House remains a thriving restaurant - where loyal customers come for both the food and the atmosphere.

"The food is very good... but at the same time - the history," said one patron. "Just think of how many people have come through that door all these years."

Another visitor called the experience "very special," citing the nostalgia of dining in such a historic space.

Even the menu reflects the tavern's heritage, with dishes inspired by early American cuisine.

Norden also led a major restoration of the building, carefully modernizing its infrastructure while preserving its original character - ensuring the tavern can continue serving future generations.

More than three centuries later, the '76 House stands as a rare blend of past and present - where guests can enjoy a meal while stepping directly into American history.