SUNOCO★4.91.21 miOpen · Closes 11 PM153 E MAIN ST, East Islip, NY 11730Unleaded$4.20Midgrade$5.10Premium$5.10Diesel$6.60Directions(631)335-4233WebsiteSafety: low risk (94)
SHELL1.32 miOpen 24 hours3260 SUNRISE HWY, East Islip, NY 11730Unleaded$4.26Midgrade$4.98Premium$5.50Diesel$6.50Directions(631)277-5260WebsiteSafety: safe (97)
GULF★3.81.37 miCheapest3309 SUNRISE HWY, Islip Terrace, NY 11752Unleaded$4.10Midgrade$4.50Premium$4.94Diesel—Directions(631)581-9600Safety: safe (98)