STEWARTS SHOPS #367★4.51.41 miOpen · Closes 11 PMCheapest415 COUNTY RD 78, Middletown, NY 10940Unleaded$4.00Midgrade$4.45Premium$4.90Diesel$6.40Directions(845)343-3174WebsiteSafety: low risk (94)
MONAGAN CITGO★3.82.02 miOpen 24 hours100 MONHAGEN AVE, Middletown, NY 10940Unleaded$4.06Midgrade$4.79Premium$5.14Diesel$5.10Directions(845)344-4930WebsiteSafety: safe (98)
MOBIL ON THE RUN★3.82.04 miOpen 24 hours176 W MAIN ST, Middletown, NY 10940Unleaded$4.14Midgrade$4.74Premium$5.14Diesel$6.40Directions(845)342-3337WebsiteSafety: safe (98)