BP★3.60.13 miOpen 24 hours741 MONTAUK HWY, Shirley, NY 11967Unleaded$3.96Midgrade$4.36Premium$4.80Diesel$6.30Directions(631)772-1060WebsiteSafety: low risk (87)
BOLLA MARKET★4.00.18 miOpen 24 hoursCheapest737 MONTAUK HWY, Shirley, NY 11967Unleaded$3.90Midgrade$4.30Premium$4.70Diesel$6.26Directions(631)281-8610WebsiteSafety: low risk (89)
CITGO★2.30.37 mi980 MONTAUK HWY, Shirley, NY 11967Unleaded$4.00Midgrade$4.58Premium$4.96Diesel$6.26Directions(631)772-6412WebsiteSafety: low risk (84)