PICCOZZI'S FUEL & BIKE SHOP★3.91.57 miOpen · Closes 6:30 PM177 N FERRY RD, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965Unleaded$4.30Midgrade—Premium$4.90Diesel$6.20Directions(631)749-0045WebsiteSafety: safe (100)
MR ROBERTS CONVENIENCE★3.92.96 miOpen · Closes 11:30 PMCheapest300 FRONT ST, Greenport, NY 11944Unleaded$4.21Midgrade$5.11Premium$5.61Diesel—Directions(631)333-2903Safety: safe (95)
EMPIRE3.13 mi74200 MAIN RD, Greenport, NY 11944Unleaded$4.30Midgrade—Premium$5.54Diesel—Directions(631)477-4938Safety: safe (100)