EMPIRE GAS★3.70.14 miOpen · Closes 10 PM150 LAKELAND AVE, Sayville, NY 11782Unleaded$4.22Midgrade$4.94Premium$5.34Diesel$6.74Directions(631)244-0510Safety: low risk (93)
76★3.80.42 miOpen nowCheapest292 RAILROAD AVE, Sayville, NY 11782Unleaded$4.00Midgrade$4.60Premium$5.10Diesel—Directions(631)750-5938WebsiteSafety: low risk (91)
OK PETROLEUM★4.40.78 miOpen · Closes 9 PM195 MIDDLE RD, Sayville, NY 11782Unleaded$4.40Midgrade$4.80Premium$5.30Diesel—Directions(631)218-1697Safety: safe (97)