ST JAMES CITGO★4.00.13 miCheapest386 LAKE AVE, Saint James, NY 11780Unleaded$4.20Midgrade$5.09Premium$5.44Diesel—Directions(631)862-9663Safety: low risk (91)
GULF★4.00.36 miOpen now255 LAKE AVE, Saint James, NY 11780Unleaded$4.20Midgrade$5.25Premium$5.45Diesel—Directions(631)863-6281Safety: safe (95)
BP★4.60.40 miClosed · Opens 8 AM Thu525 N COUNTRY RD, Saint James, NY 11780Unleaded$4.22Midgrade$5.32Premium$5.32Diesel—Directions(631)584-5798WebsiteSafety: safe (96)