She Thought Her 120-Year-Old St. Augustine House Was Her Forever Home. Then the Insurance Renewal Came: "It Can't Be My Forever Home if I Can't Afford It"
Susan Gregory had settled into a historic two-bedroom house in St. Augustine’s Abbott Tract district, and she planned to stay for good. Then her homeowners insurance renewal arrived, and she had one word for it. “Ludicrous” is how she described the bill to First Coast News reporter Renata Di Gregorio in June 2023. “I thought this was my forever home,” Gregory said. “It can’t be my forever home if I can’t afford it.” Her trouble started with a company she never chose. Her insurer, United Property and Casualty, went insolvent earlier that year, and her policy was taken over by a new company, Slide, according to the station. When the renewal came, her premium had gone from $8,800 to almost $36,000, more than 300 percent higher than what she used to pay. She did the math on what that money could do instead. “For that amount of money, I could replace my roof,” she said. “I could do all kinds of improvements on my house that would actually make it safer from hurricanes and storms.” Gregory told the station her home has never flooded. But it is 120 years old, and its roof is original. Those two facts are likely