CITGO★4.11.38 miOpen · Closes 11:59 PMCheapest650 CR-1, Pine Island, NY 10969Unleaded$4.10Midgrade$4.90Premium$5.00Diesel$6.30Directions(845)258-4262WebsiteSafety: safe (100)
MALABAR GULF★4.71.41 miOpen · Closes 11:59 PM642 PINE ISLAND TPKE, Pine Island, NY 10969Unleaded$4.10Midgrade$4.90Premium$5.10Diesel—Directions(845)981-7102Safety: safe (100)
FREDERICK'S3.50 mi517 STATE RT 284, Sussex, NJ 07461Unleaded$4.19Midgrade$4.50Premium$4.79Diesel$6.87DirectionsSafety: safe (100)