Chestnut Market★3.50.34 miOpen 24 hours75 DUTCH HILL RD, Orangeburg, NY 10962Unleaded$5.00Midgrade$5.70Premium$6.00Diesel$7.00Directions(845)680-6710WebsiteSafety: safe (96)
May Auto★4.50.81 miOpen nowCheapest300 ROUTE 303, Orangeburg, NY 10962Unleaded$4.30Midgrade$4.70Premium$4.90Diesel—Directions(845)359-8392Safety: safe (98)
Sinclair★4.31.54 miOpen 24 hours17 ROUTE 303, Blauvelt, NY 10913Unleaded$4.40Midgrade$5.10Premium$5.30Diesel$6.40Directions(845)365-3464WebsiteSafety: safe (100)