CUMBERLAND FARMS #001587★4.02.76 miOpen · Closes 12 AM1630 STATE ROUTE 94, New Windsor, NY 12553Unleaded$3.99Midgrade$5.18Premium$5.38Diesel—Directions(845)496-0308WebsiteSafety: safe (100)
MOBIL★3.83.82 miOpen 24 hours1001 ROUTE 94, New Windsor, NY 12553Unleaded$4.10Midgrade$4.70Premium$5.30Diesel$6.20Directions(845)569-0811WebsiteSafety: low risk (93)
CITGO Vails Gate★3.83.89 miOpen 24 hoursCheapest419 WINDSOR HIGHWAY, Vails Gate, NY 12584Unleaded$3.94Midgrade$4.58Premium$4.78Diesel—Directions(845)562-5100WebsiteSafety: low risk (93)