SUNOCO★4.20.23 miOpen 24 hours1219 MONTAUK HWY, Mastic, NY 11950Unleaded$4.00Midgrade$4.46Premium$4.86Diesel$6.20Directions(631)281-9777WebsiteSafety: low risk (89)
CITGO★2.30.36 mi980 MONTAUK HWY, Shirley, NY 11967Unleaded$4.00Midgrade$4.58Premium$4.96Diesel$6.26Directions(631)772-6412WebsiteSafety: low risk (82)
ALLIANCE 20240.67 miCheapest1525 MONTAUK HWY, Mastic, NY 11950Unleaded$3.90Midgrade$4.50Premium$5.10Diesel—Directions(631)395-1350Safety: low risk (94)