SUNOCO★4.90.36 miOpen · Closes 11 PM153 E MAIN ST, East Islip, NY 11730Unleaded$4.00Midgrade$5.10Premium$5.50Diesel$6.30Directions(631)335-4233WebsiteSafety: low risk (89)
CARLETON AVE MART★4.40.96 miOpen 24 hoursCheapest171 CARLETON AVE, East Islip, NY 11730Unleaded$3.90Midgrade$4.40Premium$5.00Diesel$6.30Directions(631)581-6983WebsiteSafety: safe (95)
SAMCO★4.61.10 miOpen · Closes 11 PM239 CARLETON AVE, East Islip, NY 11730Unleaded$4.00Midgrade$4.80Premium$5.30Diesel$6.60Directions(631)802-2442WebsiteSafety: safe (97)