2 DOWN, 2 MORE TO GO: N.D. Texas Joins S.D. Texas In Holding Text Messages Are Not Telephone Calls Under the TCPA
After a wave of decisions holding that text messages qualify as “telephone calls” under the TCPA, we now have two of the four federal districts in Texas reaching the opposite conclusion: text messages are not “telephone calls” under § 227(c)(5)! And with no Fifth Circuit decision resolving the issue, this split is certainly one worth watching. You may recall that just last week, the Southern District of Texas became the first federal district in Texas to hold that text messages do not qualify as telephone calls for purposes of the TCPA’s DNC provisions in Siringi v. Crust Pizza . Well, now the Northern District of Texas has joined the party! In Starling v. What If Holdings LLC , 2026 WL 3536298 (N.D. Tex. Nov. 16, 2026) the Northern District of Texas granted the Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss, finding that the Plaintiff could not maintain either of her TCPA claims based solely on the receipt of unwanted text messages. Specifically, the Court held that text messages do not qualify as “telephone calls” under § 227(c)(5) and separately dismissed the Plaintiff’s claim based on the FCC’s caller-identification regulation. The case involved a putative class action in which the Plaintiff alleged that the