BP★3.90.10 miOpen 24 hours156 W MAIN ST, Babylon, NY 11702Unleaded$4.34Midgrade$4.86Premium$5.34Diesel—Directions(631)669-9793WebsiteSafety: low risk (87)
CITGO★1.00.66 miCheapest410 MONTAUK HWY, West Islip, NY 11795Unleaded$4.16Midgrade—Premium$5.16Diesel$6.46Directions(631)321-6070Safety: safe (98)
BOLLA MARKET★4.10.67 miOpen 24 hours409 MONTAUK HWY, West Islip, NY 11795Unleaded$4.35Midgrade$4.95Premium$5.15Diesel$6.35Directions(631)422-3133WebsiteSafety: safe (98)