undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
User since undefined NaN
Council’s approval of bar a bad precedent
2025-09-17
The Council’s approval of a bar in Kemo Sabe sets a bad precedent. Council members Ben Davis and Guiseppe Caltabiano said at a recent candidate forum that they supported approval of the conditional use permit because they don’t want to pick “winners” and “losers,” and they feel obliged to approve most CUPs to avoid lawsuits. Candidate Nathan Dugan expressed a similar sentiment and said he would have approved the CUP. These comments demonstrate a fundamental misunderstanding of the City’s responsibilities. A CUP is not a property right. Activities not listed as permissive uses are either prohibited entirely or allowed only if identified as a conditional use and approved by Council. As such, a CUP is an exception to property restrictions. It is a special allowance the City has broad discretion to deny or approve, so long as the City does not act in an arbitrary and capricious manner. Having set this precedent, the City could face lawsuits if other retail stores seek to operate a bar but are denied. Under Whitefish Code Section 11-7-8(J)(7)(e), the Council must find that the proposed use is compatible with the established community character. Whitefish’s established community character is not one of combination retail stores/bars.