undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Council delays decision on Toscana PUD changes
By Bob Mudge,
1 days agoVENICE — Toscana Isles residents who are trying to keep two parcels that bookend their community along Knights Trail Road from being developed may be a bit more hopeful after Tuesday’s City Council meeting.
The crosshatched areas are where SVN Commercial Partners is seeking access from Knights Trail Road. They can’t be accessed from within Toscana Isles, to the right, and access from Gene Green Road, at top, has been denied. It wouldn’t provide access to the smaller parcel in any event.
The Council didn’t reject a proposed planned unit development, but it also didn’t approve it, as the Planning Commission had recommended.
SVN Commercial Partners owns the two parcels, at the northwest and southwest corners of Toscana Isles. They’re both included in the Toscana Isles PUD. It requested two changes to the PUD: including townhomes as a permitted use on the two parcels, as they are in a large part of Toscana Isles, and allowing access to them from Knights Trail Road.
The connectivity plan for the PUD originally contemplated internal access to the northern parcel, but Toscana Isles Community Development District prevailed in a lawsuit brought by a prior owner claiming an easement across community property.
Last year, the Council rejected access from Gene Green Road to the north, citing safety issues. Using Knights Trail Road wasn’t pursued then because of concerns the county, which owns the road, wouldn’t grant permission.
It’s the only option now, Planning and Zoning Director Roger Clark told the Council.
The Planning Commission voted to recommend approval after Assistant City Attorney Karla Armstrong informed the commissioners that a property owner has to be granted access to its property.
City Attorney Kelly Fernandez reiterated that opinion Tuesday, telling the Council that if some form of access to the parcels isn’t granted, “I strongly suspect we will see a regulatory taking claim.”
The county has now indicated a variance for access from Knights Trail Road will be granted, Clark said.
Council members weren’t happy about being “caught between a rock and a hard place,” as Mayor Jim Boldt put it.
“We don’t necessarily like the way this is playing out, but we have to make a decision,” he said.
The Council ended up making a decision not to make a decision, at least not yet.
Despite feeling “conflicted,” Council Member Kevin Engelke moved to approve the proposed PUD amendment, and Boldt seconded it for discussion purposes after no one else did.
It immediately ran into opposition.
Council Member Lloyd Weed said he couldn’t vote for it because SVN hadn’t offered a study showing access from Knights Trail Road would be safer than from Gene Green Road. He suggested the matter be continued to allow the applicant to address the safety issue.
“That part of Knights Trail is a mess,” Council Member Rick Howard said.
Engelke said that he, too, liked the idea of a safety study, so he withdrew his motion.
Ashley Bloom, a principal in SVN, said it could work on a safety study regarding access to the northern parcel, but Knights Trail Road is the only option for the southern one.
The Council voted to continue the discussion to its Jan. 12 meeting, to give SVN time to submit a safety study.