Skip to main content
    Patriots Most Concerning Position is the Obvious One: Quarterback

    Which Alabama Rookies Will Have Biggest NFL Impact? All Things CW

    The Crimson Tide had 10 former players selected in the 2023 NFL Draft, but the No. 1-overall pick may not help his team the most this season.

    In this story:

    Alabama Crimson Tide
    Alabama Crimson Tide

    The dust has settled. The contracts are being signed. The players have attended rookie camps and taken their first NFL practice snaps. 

    Roughly one month after the 2023 NFL Draft was held the folks at NFL Draft Bible have finished the final evaluations about how well each team fared with its selections, and which players are the best fit for their developing talents.  

    Rookie projections aren't easy, and neither were the ones done for the draft, but Ric Serritella's group has done just that for each team and every selection. We thought you might be interested to see what they came up with for the 10 Alabama Crimson Tide picks. 

    The breakdown is based on a scale on what kind of impact each player will have this season: 

    10–9.5: All Pro impact
    9.4–8.9: Pro Bowl impact
    8.8–8.0: Starter impact
    7.9–7.0: Rotational impact
    6.9–6.0: Backup impact
    5.9–Below: Practice squad impact

    For a little perspective, NFL Draft Bible had linebacker Ryan Anderson Jr. rated as the second-overall prospect in the draft, with Bryce Young third. Safety Brian Branch was the its only other top-25 player at No. 22. Running back Jahmyr Gibbs was No. 41, tackle Tyler Steen No. 76, and linebacker Henry To'oTo'o No. 80. 

    Offensive lineman Emily Ekiyor Jr., who wasn't selected, was No. 90, and safety Jordan Battle wrapped up the top 100 at No. 100. 

    1. Will Anderson Jr.

    Alabama linebacker Will Anderson Jr. after being selected by the Houston Texans in the first round of the 2023 NFL Draft.

    Team: Houston Texans

    Position: Outside linebacker/Edge rusher

    Pick: Round 1, No. 3 

    A draft day trade for the ages, Houston acquired a cornerstone player to build around in Anderson. 

    Projection: 17 starts, 65 tackles, eight and a half sacks, 13 tackles for loss, two interceptions. 

    Impact Factor: 8.6

    2. Bryce Young

    Apr 27, 2023; Kansas City, MO, USA; Alabama quarterback Bryce Young with NFL commissioner Roger Goodell after he was drafted first overall by the Carolina Panthers in the first round of the 2023 NFL Draft at Union Station.

    Team: Carolina Panthers 

    Position: Quarterback 

    Pick: Round 1, No. 1

    The way the NFL evaluates quarterback prospects has been completely revolutionized and Young is just the latest exhibit. Many of the new-wave general managers believe talent trumps traits. 

    Projection: 13 starts, 189 completions, 313 attempts, 2,321 passing yards, 334 rushing yards, 20 total touchdowns, 11 interceptions.

    Impact Factor: 8.4

    3. Jahmyr Gibbs

    Jahmyr Gibbs

    Team: Detroit Lions 

    Position: Running back 

    Pick: Round 1, No. 12

    A polarizing pick. Detroit blew the Jamaal Williams negotiations and then signed David Montgomery at the same cost. Next, they pivoted to Gibbs and dealt off D’Andre Swift for a bag of chips. It’s a bit bizarre from the outside looking in. To his credit, Gibbs is talented enough to make everyone forget all of this. 

    Projection: 195 carries, 897 rushing yards, 413 receiving yards, eight touchdowns.

    Impact Factor: 8.3

    4. Tyler Steen

    Alabama offensive lineman Tyler Steen (OL43) speaks to the press at the NFL Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium.

    Team: Philadelphia Eagles

    Position: Offensive lineman  

    Pick: Round 3, No. 65

    A Senior Bowl audition at guard persuaded the team to select Steen. He should compete to start at right guard, which would allow the Cam Jurgens succession plan at center to remain intact. 

    Projection: 17 starts. 

    Impact Factor: 8.2

    5. Brian Branch

    Brian Branch at NFL Draft

    Team: Detroit Lions

    Position: Safety  

    Pick: Round 2, No.45 

    Possibly the greatest value selection of the entire draft, Branch has the potential to become a top safety in the NFL. It should be fun to watch him defy the odds!

    Projection: 17 games played, nine starts, 50 tackles, seven tackles for loss, two interceptions. 

    Impact Factor: 7.7

    6. Cameron Latu

    Alabama Crimson Tide tight end Cameron Latu (81) warms up before a game against the Mississippi State Bulldogs at Bryant-Denny Stadium.

    Team: San Francisco 49ers

    Position: Tight end

    Pick: Round 3, No. 101 

    There could be mismatch opportunities for Latu to take advantage of when lined up in packages with George Kittle; a nice complimentary underneath target.

    Projection: 10 games played, 22 catches, 295 receiving yards, two touchdowns.

    Impact Factor: 7.2

    7. Byron Young

    Byron Young Can Inject Life into Raiders Defensive Line

    Team: Las Vegan Raiders 

    Position: Defensive lineman

    Pick: Round 3, No. 70

    Beefing up the defensive front was clearly a priority within the organization and Young helps to strengthen the depth. 

    Projection: 13 games played, 22 tackles, one sacks, two tackles for loss. 

    Impact Factor: 6.6

    8. Jordan Battle

    Alabama Crimson Tide defensive back Jordan Battle (9) celebrates his interception against the Kansas State Wildcats during the first half in the 2022 Sugar Bowl at Caesars Superdome.

    Team: Cincinnati Bengals

    Position: Safety

    Pick: Round 3, No. 95 

    With the offseason departures of Jessie Bates III and Vonn Bell, the selection of Battle will help fortify the safety group. He can play both safety spots and boost the special teams unit. 

    Projection: Plays 15 games, makes 23 tackles, has four pass deflections. 

    Impact Factor: 6.4

    9. Henry To'oTo'o

    Alabama linebacker Henry To'o To'o (10) celebrates after helping on tackle against Mercer Saturday, Sept. 11, 2021, in Bryant-Denny Stadium.

    Team: Houston Texans

    Position: Interior linebacker 

    Pick: Round 5, No. 167

    Other than special teams, To’oTo’o will spend a year in the strength and conditioning program as a developmental player. 

    Projection: 10 games played, 15 tackles, two tackles for loss.

    Impact Factor: 6.3

    10. DeMarcco Hellams

    DeMarcco Hellams

    Team: Atlanta Falcons 

    Position: Safety 

    Pick: Round 7, No. 224 

    The safety spot has been completely overhauled during the past two offseasons, mission accomplished. Hellams will begin as a special teams ace and backup.

    Projection: 10 games played, eight tackles. 

    Impact Factor: 6.2

    Christopher Walsh's notes column All Things CW regularly appears on BamaCentral. 

    SEE ALSO: The Complete Alabama Crimson Tide in the NFL Database
    © 2024 ABG-SI LLC. SPORTS ILLUSTRATED IS A REGISTERED TRADEMARK OF ABG-SI LLC. - All Rights Reserved. The content on this site is for entertainment and educational purposes only. All betting content is intended for an audience ages 21+. All advice, including picks and predictions, is based on individual commentators’ opinions and not that of Minute Media or its related brands. All picks and predictions are suggestions only. No one should expect to make money from the picks and predictions discussed on this website. For more information, please read our Legal Disclaimer. Gambling content intended for 21+. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, crisis counseling and referral services can be accessed by calling 1-800-GAMBLER.