undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
'A cautionary tale': Problems with hydrants, water during L.A. fires brings infrastructure, preparedness to forefront
By MIKE SUNNUCKS APG Media,
2025-01-23There are an estimated 9 million fire hydrants in the U.S.
Some hydrants ran dry and failed to operate during the recent raging wildfires that decimated Malibu, Pacific Palisades and other parts of Los Angeles because of water pressure and water supplies problems.
California Gov. Gavin Newsom — who has faced significant criticism along with Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass over the fires — has ordered investigations into what went wrong with the fires, including the issues with hydrants losing pressure and not working.
Jeff Wenninger, CEO of Law Enforcement Consultants LLC (a public safety advisory firm) and a former Los Angeles Police Department lieutenant, says other communities should take heed of the Southern California fires.
“The Los Angeles wildfires are a cautionary tale for every community, showing that preparedness is non-negotiable,” Wenninger said. “One key lesson is the importance of maintaining critical infrastructure. Fire hydrants, reservoirs, and water systems must be inspected and repaired regularly.”
He pointed to tree trimming in the Los Angeles urban forest and a local reservoir that was empty at the time of the fires earlier this month.
Wenninger said Los Angeles has the largest tree count in the country, with 700,000 trees and 6,500 miles of tree-lined streets.
“But tree trimming happens on a 15-year cycle—far too long in fire-prone areas. Nearby communities trim every 2–5 years, significantly reducing their risk. This is a clear area where improvement is both possible and necessary,” he said.
“Then, there’s the failure of the Santa Ynez Reservoir, which sat empty for over a year due to a torn cover awaiting repair. Fixing it would’ve cost $130,000—a fraction of the damages caused by the fires,” he said.
Wenninger said a regular inspection and maintenance regime as well as smart technologies that can detect water and firefighting infrastructure problems should be looked at in California and across the country.
Mitch Francis, a Beverly Hills-based real estate developer and author who delves into policy matters, said communities need to look at and potentially up their current funding and resource levels for water reserves, firefighting equipments and forest and brush management.
“Building methodologies and codes must be restructured to move away from building with flammable materials. Building wood-frame structures is tantamount to building with gasoline. We have to build with more nonflammable materials such as concrete and steel,” Francis said.
He also said there could be reimagined volunteer fire departments in local neighborhoods to help battle blazes
“We have to reinstate and proliferate the old idea of volunteer fire departments, but on an extremely local level of small communities, down to even just a few blocks. Small enclaves of homeowners can own their own water/hose truck and be trained in maintaining and using it,” Francis said.
Year-round vigilance
Fire departments and local governments across the country are also watching and looking to learn lessons from the California fires, which continue to spark in the Los Angeles and San Diego area.
In Sarasota County on Florida’s west coast, county officials said the California fires reinforce the need for year-round mitigation and clearings for fire-prone areas, year-around monitoring and maintenance of water infrastructure and shows the need for brushfire training and mutual aid emergency planning with other jurisdictions.
Sarasota County, which has a population of more than 469,000 people, operates 7,800 fire hydrants in unincorporated areas and 1,400 miles of water mains.
“All potable water supply mains, back-flow preventers, and fire hydrants are approved, inspected, and maintained by the Sarasota County Public Utilities Department,” the county said in a statement
The Florida county abides by National Fire Protection Association standards that calls for fire hydrants to be inspected annually and after each use.
‘Prevention and preparation’Takami Clark, spokesperson for the city of Bozeman in Montana, said her city is also watching the California fires unfold.
“We recognize that wildfire is a major concern and our best strategies to deal with this growing problem are prevention and preparation,” Clark said.
The Montana city of more than 57,300 people has roughly 3,100 fire hydrants and 350 miles of water mains that are supplied by four water tanks with 16 million gallons of storage.
The city’s water and sewer division maintains the hydrants and mains.
Bozeman officials said they conduct leak detection surveys and inspections, including to make sure they are working in the wintertime.
“We try to accomplish one-third of our hydrants each year for this task. We also flow about a one-fourth of our fire hydrants each year and flow test random spots of another 5% of our system each year,” Clark said.
Clark said Bozeman has not had any problems with its hydrants, noting that the city only utilizes two pump stations to get water to higher elevations.
Actio
nable lessons
Rebekah Thurston, public information officer for the Wilmington Fire Department in North Carolina said the agency “directly inspected 6,294 fire hydrants” in 2024 and any repairs are done promptly.
“This includes both public hydrants owned by the Cape Fear Public Utility Authority (CFPUA) and private hydrants,” she said. The North Carolina city has a population of close 122,700 people.
“Our hydrant management software uses GPS for precise location tracking, records hydrant details, captures maintenance needs, and includes a comprehensive inspection checklist,” Thurston said, adding that inspections are conducted throughout the year.
She said WFD conducts post-incident reviews of major national and international disasters and weather events.
“These reviews are essential for enhancing safety, fostering continuous improvement, and identifying actionable lessons to improve future responses,” she said.
‘You’re vulnerable’Michael Coffey, a partner with New York-based law firm Coffey Modica LLP (who previously served as fire commissioner and on the city council in Norwalk, Connecticut), said local governments need to look if they are doing enough emergency preparedness for wildfires and other natural disasters and make sure water systems and other infrastructure are in working conditions.
“This is an epic failure of a lot of different agencies,” Coffey said, of the California wildfires.
Coffey said working fire hydrants are tied to insurance premiums for nearby. He said water infrastructure isn’t always high on government spending lists, but municipalities and counties need to take fresh and regular looks at those needs.
“Infrastructure is not sexy. People don’t get jazzed up about it,” Coffey said.
He said communities also need to look at building codes (including materials used for housing and commercial buildings), zoning, current and future challenges with water rights and insurance quandaries with fire seasons getting longer and more destructive hurricanes and other storms due to weather changes.
Eric Brown, founder and CEO of Orlando-based Imperio Consulting and former U.S. Army Green Beret, puts fighting fires in military terms.
“There’s a tenet I’ve carried with me from my time in Special Forces: You’re only as strong as your supply lines. In the context of firefighting, that means your water infrastructure must be rock-solid,” Brown said.
He said the lessons of Los Angeles should be “to shore up” water delivery systems and infrastructure and be on the watch for aging hydrants and pipes and insufficient or fluctuating water pressure.
He said local governments need to collaborate more closely with utilities and treat water infrastructure as a “critical asset.”
“When the fires raged, every second counted. Without robust water pressure and well-maintained hydrants, firefighters are effectively sent into battle with half their ammunition. Communities and fire departments across the country should take note: If your infrastructure can’t handle peak demand at a moment’s notice, you’re vulnerable,” Brown said.