undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Mayor's race center stage at GOP debate
By Staff,
2026-03-03Editor’s note: The photo accompanying this story has been updated with another image from the debate.In what could be considered the opening salvo in what has the makings of a bruising 2026 election campaign season, the Cocke County Republican Party hosted a candidate debate / town hall event Monday ahead of the party’s May 5 primary.
The event at the picturesque setting of The Estate at Sweetwater Creek was open to all GOP candidates who will be appearing on the primary ballot, including several who are running unopposed in the primary. Those running unopposed, including Cocke County Sheriff CJ Ball, were given time to introduce themselves before candidates running for office that have primary opponents. Those offices are county mayor, circuit court clerk, county clerk and superintendent of roads.
The questions for the candidates were submitted by the public to the Republican party and eight questions were selected for each office. Each candidate had two minutes to respond and one minute for rebuttal.
The event, attended by around 150 people, was emceed by local GOP party vice chair Macie Reed, who is also the Cocke County property assessor.
County Mayor
While all the contested races are garnering interest, the race for county mayor has drawn the most attention with incumbent first term Mayor Rob Mathis being challenged by real estate agent/appraiser Joe Shults.
The candidates sparred on several issues.
The issue of replacing the county jail, essentially destroyed by flooding from Hurricane Helen in 2024, was a hot topic with funding from FEMA in question and the cost of building a jail that will meet state certification being more than FEMA is willing to provide.
Notably, the Cocke County Jail has not been certified for several years. Mathis noted that construction on the justice center got underway prior to COVID and costs have escalated since then.
Shults pointed out that the Hamblen County Detention Center was recently completed with 621 beds and a capacity of up to 750 inmates, much larger than the Cocke County Jail that had been in use.
According to media reports, the Hamblen County justice center cost more than $100 million to complete..
Shults said the reimbursement rate for federal prisoners held in jail is $120.84 per day. Mathis stated that amount was incorrect. Sheriff Ball stated the rate for federal prisoners is $55 per day, considerably less than what Shults stated. Ball also said the reimbursement for state prisoners is $41 per day.
Mathis said State Sen. Steve Southerland has asked the state for an additional $20 million in funding to help cover the construction if the county is able to get the funding from FEMA to cover the basic 88-bed jail which the county lost with the annex.
Shults proposed that the county should have its own ambulance service with Shults claiming nearby counties with ambulance services make money form those services. It was a claim Mathis denied.
Mathis retorted that he has spoken to several such counties and that they figure a loss in their budget from their own ambulance service. Mathis said the cost of the agreement with Priority Ambulance provides service without the additional costs of owning a service.
Shults said those counties would not be operating a service if it was not profitable.
The discussion then turned to recruitment and industrial development with Mathis noting that “for the first time in 50 years we have a new industrial park. He also pointed to the Cocke County School Innovation Center and its role in training students to enter the workforce immediately after graduating. He then announced that there is a site visit next month at the Innovation Park. He said he could not reveal the name at this time, but said it is a name that would be recognized.
There was also a discussion about higher property values.
Shults explained that the prices have gone up because people who are retiring are leaving states where the cost of living is much higher. He said if they sell a property in another state for $1 million and they come here and buy a property for $350,000, they are getting a place to live and they have $650,000 left to add to their retirement funds.
When zoning was discussed, Mathis said zoning was a necessity to help protect property owners. Shults did not say he was against zoning, but he felt other counties should have been contacted to find out what recommendations there were out there. Shults also said he felt that zoning was rushed.
Mathis said when he goes to the meetings for county mayors, those who have counties without zoning are the counties getting “the stuff that nobody wants because there are no restrictions.”
Shults then brought up the $378,000 TIF sales tax payment that was to be paid to Love’s Travel Center per an agreement. The funds that were to be paid to Love’s were paid toward the Innovation Park construction, per an audit report for the IDB for fiscal year 2024.
Mathis pointed out that the funds were not sent to Love’s by the IDB, which is a different entity than the county. Per the audit, on Sept. 2, 2021 the IDB entered into a loan agreement with Love’s Travel Center, which was prior to Mathis taking office.
Mathis said the issues regarding the TIF funds occurred under the leadership of the past partnership director. That director resigned in mid-2024.
The debate between the mayoral candidates was pointed and intense at times with Shults displaying visceral signs of his displeasure or disagreement.
Superintendent of Roads
Kenneth Ford, who previously served as superintendent of roads is challenging the current roads superintendent, Dwayne “Bullett” McCallister. The two have worked together in the past and there was little disagreement between the two.
When asked about the protocol used for deciding which roads will be fixed, McCallister said he looks at the road age, condition, traffic count and road damage when determining which road to address first.
Ford said he will go with the worst first. He said population or traffic and how dangerous the road is would be considered as well.
Both men pointed out there are so many roads in the county, and so many miles of roads they are very limited on the amount of work they can do on roads.
The men hugged one another at the conclusion of their debate.
Circuit Court Clerk
Circuit Court Clerk Kristy Nease is being challenged by Jennifer Arms. Arms had also run for the office in 2018 and Nease was elected to office. The two candidates got into a spirited, almost heated, discussion about the job duties, recidivism, customer service and employee retention.
The debate was intense regarding staffing. Arms pointed out that the office is understaffed and that employees have been leaving for other positions within the courthouse. However, Nease attributed those departures to low pay. They disagreed over whether a standardized courthouse pay scale exists with Arms stating such a pay scale exists. Nease said there was no such scale.
Arms also accused Nease of turning in an incorrect budget, creating a shortfall of $65,000 to $85,000 — an error Nease acknowledged. Both pledged to keep current employees if elected. The exchange ended on a sharp note when Nease suggested Arms was undermining her staff, a claim Arms denied.
A question was then asked regarding what the circuit court clerk would do to reduce recidivism of criminals in the county.
Nease said that occurs when someone violates an agreement with the probation officer.
“Our only ability to assist is to ensure we maintain accurate records,” Nease said.
She said then she must ensure those records are then sent on to the appropriate offices, authorities and officials.
Nease further explained that the attorney representing the individual is responsible for seeing that their client follows through with the court-ordered requirements.
Arms said that an individual may not know what they need to do to stay on track and complete. She said that those in the court system could be helped through the process and get their driver’s license back.
Nease said that driver’s license reinstatement is not recidivism, but recidivism involves the individual not returning to jail.
Cocke County Clerk
Incumbent Cocke County Clerk Shalee McClure is being challenged by Danielle Moore Smith. A significant portion of the discussion centered on McClure’s absences over the past year, which she attributed to a series of serious hardships, including the loss of her sister to stage four cancer and her own hospitalizations for a kidney stone and sepsis.
McClure credited her staff for keeping the office running during that time.
Smith emphasized that she would maintain a consistent full-time presence drawing on her experience operating a family business, Brock’s Market, that stayed open through difficult times.
“I would be there at 8 a.m. and work all day,” Smith said. “I’d be there until we closed.”
The two also disagreed on whether the clerk should run her own cash drawer at the front counter, with Smith pointing to other counties where clerks do so, while McClure noted auditors had advised against the practice — a detail The Newport Plain Talk confirmed directly with the auditor.
Both agreed on keeping Saturday office hours, with McClure pointing out she was the one who originally brought those hours back. Smith pledged to retain the current office staff if elected.
When it came to experience, McClure pointed to nearly 26 years in the county clerk’s office, while Smith noted her 20 years of managerial experience and around 10 years working in a clerk’s office