undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
▶︎Rapp BZA denies Huntly setback request for new home
Rappahannock County’s Board of Zoning Appeals unanimously denied a Huntly property owner’s request to sharply reduce required setbacks for a new home, concluding the parcel could still be built on without a variance.
The ruling means property owner Ryan Raybould cannot place the house in the location proposed near side and rear property lines.
Board members said other buildable sites exist on the 14-acre parcel, even if they would be more difficult or expensive to use.
Zoning Administrator Michelle L. Somers denied Raybould’s Zoning application, and the county accepted the Variance application on August 4.
The request sought to reduce the required 100-foot side and rear setbacks to 19 feet and 50 feet, respectively, for a home and septic field in the Huntly area.
Raybould could not attend Wednesday’s meeting. A friend, Will Melton, spoke on his behalf.
He said the chosen homesite made sense because it already had an access road, a long-used camping area, and an open clearing that would avoid major tree clearing.
“[Raybould] does not want to go in and bulldoze and take down trees and change the property at all if he can do it,” Melton told the board.
He said the site would cause “the least disruption of the property as it is now.”
Melton also said the owner planned to live in the proposed 2,000 square-foot A-Frame dwelling full time; not operate a short-term rental.
“This is his primary residence,” he said. “He’s going to live there 365 days a year.”
But neighbors and board members said the case did not meet Virginia’s or the county’s legal standard for a variance, which requires an exceptional hardship tied to the property itself, not simply a more convenient building site.
Karen Hunt, who spoke during public comment, called the request “a bit of a big ask.”
She said the proposed reductions of 50% and 81% were significant, especially in a Conservation-zoned district where steep slopes, rock, and septic concerns are common.
“You can’t grant a variance for privilege or convenience,” Hunt said.
She argued the applicant had not shown that a house could not be built elsewhere on the lot while meeting the ordinance.
Another speaker, Anita Ramos, said the county had denied less substantial requests in the past.
“I do not see why a house could meet the criteria that the county has set up,” she told the board.
Board members appeared sympathetic to the property’s terrain. Several noted that steep land, trees, boulders, and uphill pump septic systems are common realities for homeowners in the county.
Still, they said those challenges were not unique enough to justify moving a house so close to neighboring land.
BZA Member I. Christopher Parrish said a neighbor’s objection letter carried weight.
“These ordinances are created to protect our citizens, that is neighbors,” Parrish said. “If somebody wants to do something that’s not out of the ordinary, the first thing they really should do is go to each and every one of the neighbors.”
Members also raised concerns about privacy, visual impacts, possible erosion, emergency access, and placing a drain field close to a property line.
BZA Chair Chris Bird said the key issue was whether the property could still be reasonably used without a variance.
“It ought to be done as a last resort,” he said, “to enable the owner to use the property as opposed to being unable to use the property,” Bird said.
After discussing the county’s required legal findings one by one, the board agreed none supported approval. Members said the hardship was not unique; nearby properties faced similar topography, and granting the request could harm adjacent owners and the character of the area.
The vote to deny the application was unanimous.
Several members suggested the owner may ultimately be better off building closer to Woodland Lane or at another location on the tract. One said the board believed “he’ll be happier in the other place.”
The decision leaves the owner free to pursue a different homesite on the property, but not the one requested in the appeal. For neighboring landowners in the county’s steep conservation areas, the vote reinforced how narrowly Rappahannock County applies to setback variances.
The post ▶︎Rapp BZA denies Huntly setback request for new home first appeared on The Piedmont Journal Recorder.