undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Indiana

Purdue professors discuss post-election results, political trends

By BRAETON LAMBRIGHT Asst. Campus Editor,

9 days ago
https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=2WK792_1H04PU7g00
Election signs line the sidewalk about 9:20 a.m. Nov. 3 at the CoRec. Alex Jarboe | Staff Photographer

Following the midterm election results, Pi Sigma Alpha, Purdue's Political Science Honor Society, hosted a panel featuring three Purdue professors and their opinions.

The first professor to speak was Mollie Cohen, a political science professor at Purdue whose academic focus is in Latin American politics. She responded to a question regarding how classes can help students understand what happened on Election Day.

“Since post Nixon, post Watergate, we have not seen a party win by margins that large,” Cohen said.

Cohen mentioned a class she teaches, called Electioneering Around the World, a class dedicated to studying formal and informal rules and the things that shape elections.

She prefaced her statement by stating that all institutions have their benefits and downsides.

“They all imply costs, and they all imply weighing a series of trade-offs to benefit one sort of perspective of representation or participation versus another,” Cohen said.

Cohen said that U.S. institutions differ from those around the world with issues like gerrymandering and winner-takes-all elections.

“It's very unusual, and with respect to the rest of the world, most places have larger constituencies that don't get redrawn; the constituency stays the same,” Cohen said.

She also mentioned cases throughout U.S. history when the government used its power to disenfranchise minority voters, except for some states fighting back. She used the case of Los Angeles County, which refused to send in voter rolls when the government accused 20,000 voters of being non-citizens because they had Latino names, according to an article published by the Campaign Legal Center.

The mention of Congress’ push to install harsher voter ID regulations was brought up, with Cohen looking at it as a policy trade-off.

“There is one goal is to have as many people as possible participate in elections because that legitimates the outcome,” Cohen said. “The other is to restrict access to the polls to make sure that no one who is not eligible to vote can vote. That was an extremely restrictive set of (rules) that inarguably would have stripped many people from the polls.”

After Cohen concluded her discussion, the floor went to Jesse Crosson, a political science professor who specializes in American politics.

Crosson said the thing that surprised him the most about the election was how nationalized the results were.

“Nationalization basically means that election results, the whole way from local offices up to national offices, sort of swing all in the same direction,” Crosson said.

He mentioned that there wasn’t much variation in the size of the wave according to things he thought would shift which way a group might have voted.

“You would think if economic conditions were especially bad in one area, the swing would be really big for Democrats, and maybe in better areas it would be smaller. We didn't see very much of that,” Crosson said.

According to Crosson, even establishing local roots was insignificant for incumbants looking to avoid being voted out.

“My impression is that local roots were probably the least important that they've been in any election in recent memory,” Crosson said. “This is of course anecdotal. … But, Susan Collins losing in Maine is a big deal.”

Something that Crosson looked at was nationalization and how modern politics need cooperation between parties, but according to him, there is a concerning trend due to how many potential vetoes the system has. He mentioned that without flexibility, it is hard to establish coalitions between parties.

“Another way that they've nationalized is by the president intervening in state legislative races, like what happened here in Indiana,” Crosson said. “Nationalization helped people like Spencer Deery here in Indiana 23 and Greg Goode down in Terre Haute. Why? Because they gained their own personal vote by being challenged by the president of the United States.”

Crosson then gave up the floor to Valeria Sinclair-Chapman, a political science professor who spoke on the meaning of the election and democratic recovery.

You can tell people that inflation is going down, that gas prices are going to come back to where they need to come back to as soon as the war is over,” Sinclair-Chapman said. “But you can't tell them when the war is going to be over, and you cannot explain to them why it costs them 40% more to fill up their gas tanks, right?”

At a G7 summit in June 2026, President Donald Trump called affordability a fake word, but Sinclair-Chapman said that calling it a hoax was a mistake young voters probably didn’t agree with.

She also mentioned that both parties are viewed unfavorably in the U.S. in terms of trust and public confidence.

“A Gallup survey said that only 43% of Americans view the Democratic Party favorably. Thirty-five percent view the Republican Party favorably. The unfavorables for both parties far outweigh the majorities,” Sinclair-Chapman said. “A little bit more than 20% of Americans approve of Congress, while almost 70% disapprove.”

Sinclair-Chapman also brought up the question of what the Democratic Party is going to do following the blue wave.

“So now they've had this big blue wave and this swing. What (are) you gonna do with it? How (are) you gonna manage it? How (are) you gonna manage your own caucus when you got 80 new members?” Sinclair-Chapman said.

Sinclair-Chapman also shared her thoughts on voter ID.

“You add voter ID (and) other kinds of constraints on the vote; these are tactics, not necessarily about election security or integrity; they're really tactics to reshape who was going to show up at the polls to incentivize or disincentivize,” Sinclair-Chapman said.

One of the last things mentioned is how people have to be careful with the language they use and how Americans are persuaded by information.

“(The) Republicans’ claim that fraud is rampant at the polls actually made them stay home. If my vote doesn't count, then I'm not going to go,” Sinclair-Chapman said. “For Democrats, it motivated them to go to the polls. It actually kind of worked in two very different directions.”

After Sinclair-Chapman's section, the group opened the floor to comments and questions from the audience.

One question was whether, in upcoming years, Democrats who flipped seats might pass policies that are more extreme than the public wanted.

“I just like to see them try to do policy. That's step one. Increasingly, the middle members of Congress, particularly in the House, but increasingly in the Senate, really are not that interested in policy,” Crosson said. “I mean, even if it's extreme, at least they're trying.”

Sinclair-Chapman added that overplaying their hand is normal and that the current administration overplayed theirs, which came with backlash.

Another comment mentioned the surprise at the age of the people elected, and Cohen mentioned that the average age went down by three years.

“There are a lot of young people who need representation, and it just turns out that when you're 25, the things you want are very different from when you're 80,” Cohen said. “It’s hard to represent the interests of a bunch of 25-year-olds if you're not going to your district and talking to them and hearing their concerns.”

Cohen also brought up that voters' decisions in this election were based on people talking about corruption and democracy issues.

“Everyone gets mad about corruption, and everyone thinks all politicians are corrupt because many politicians are, in fact, corrupt,” Cohen said. “So I think the younger candidates did a much better job of picking up that energy and reflecting it back to people.”

Another audience member asked whether a lack of major influence from third parties means there is going to be a major shift in the definition of the parties.

Crosson mentioned how the progressive movement was started in the Republican Party, that these parties exist to win elections and that they adapt to the changes.

“That's what Trump has done to the Republican Party of today. It's fundamentally different from the Republican Party of 10 years ago. It is unrecognizable,” Cohen said. “The world has changed.”

— Additional reporting contributed by Addison Walter, campus editor

Comments