undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Opinion: Blue asteroid strikes Forsyth County Republicans
By Algenon Cash,
19 hours agoThe first sign that Forsyth County Republicans might be in real trouble came a year before the midterms, in Kernersville.
In November 2025, Democrats won three of the five seats on the town’s Board of Aldermen. Among the winners was retired Brig. Gen. JR Gorham, a former Republican who had become a Democrat. He would go on to serve as mayor pro tem. Kernersville was hardly where I expected to see Democrats capture a majority on the board, which is precisely why the results caught my attention.
I began warning local Republicans that something had changed. They could dismiss the outcome as an isolated municipal election, or they could consider the possibility that voters who had supported Republicans for years were growing tired of what the party had become. I believed it was the latter. By then, I had spent nearly two years speaking out about the party’s retreat from conservative principles, and I expected the consequences to eventually show up at the ballot box.
But I never imagined they would hit so close to home, or so hard.
On Nov. 3, Jeff Zenger and Donny Lambeth lost their seats in the North Carolina House. Jim O’Neill lost the district attorney’s office to Amara Hunter. Democrats swept all nine seats on the Winston-Salem/Forsyth County Board of Education ballot and gained control of the county commission. The losses extended beyond the county line. Congressman Addison McDowell was defeated by Cyril Jefferson, and Virginia Foxx trails Charles Hubbard narrowly and has likely lost her seat, too.
I have known some of these people for years. I know the time they have spent away from their families, the constituent calls they have taken and the often thankless nature of public service. I have disagreed with them on policy, and at times on the direction of their party.
Lambeth spent years working on state budgets and health policy, gaining relationships and influence that mattered to Forsyth County. Zenger brought his experience in business to Raleigh. O’Neill served as district attorney for more than 15 years. Their opponents earned the right to replace them, and I am certainly not questioning the voters’ judgment. I simply believe the human side of an election is too easily overlooked when the headlines focus entirely on which party won.
My criticism of Donald Trump has been public and sustained. Some Republicans have treated that as evidence that I abandoned conservatism. I see it differently.
What troubled me most was watching Republicans abandon positions they had defended for decades. The same politicians who once ran on reducing excessive government spending suddenly had little to say about exploding deficits. The GOP positioned themselves as champions of free markets, but then suddenly embraced tariffs. Republicans in Congress also appeared increasingly comfortable with abdicating oversight to presidential executive orders they would have fiercely opposed under a Democratic administration. I could only conclude that maintaining power had become more important to many Republican leaders than defending the conservative principles they had spent their careers promoting.
I said this would end badly. But saying so from a distance is one thing. Watching people you know pay the price is another.
It would be convenient to blame every Republican loss in Forsyth County on the president. It would also be unfair. The financial problems at Winston-Salem/Forsyth County Schools demanded accountability. Democrats recruited candidates, put their names on ballots and persuaded voters to give them a chance. Each incumbent had a record that voters were entitled to examine.
Still, the size and reach of the Republican losses cannot be explained away by one school board controversy or one poorly run campaign. From legislative seats to the courthouse, voters made changes in places where Republicans had long expected to be competitive. I believe the party label, which once helped many candidates, had become a political liability.
Consider what happened with the three constitutional amendments. Roughly 60% of North Carolina voters supported proposals involving voter identification, income taxes and property taxes, even as they were electing Democrats across the state. I wouldn’t suggest that every person who voted for those amendments considers themselves conservative, but the results certainly complicate the argument that voters had turned their backs on conservative principles.
I have made this argument to Republican friends for some time. People do not owe a political party their vote simply because they agree with some of its principles. A party has to earn that support, and it can lose it. For too long, Republican leaders behaved as though voters would tolerate almost anything so long as the alternative candidate had a “D” beside their name.
The Democrats who won in Forsyth County deserve congratulations and a fair opportunity to govern. They also deserve scrutiny. Our community’s problems did not disappear on election night, and voters who demanded accountability from Republicans should expect the same from their replacements.
As for my friends who lost, I hope they know their service has not been erased by one election. I remember the years, the work and the commitment, even where we disagreed. I can believe the Republican Party brought this political reckoning upon itself and still feel genuine sadness for the people caught in it.
What happened in Kernersville a year earlier was a warning that I hoped local Republicans would take seriously. Instead, Nov. 3 brought losses deeper than even I anticipated.
Many of my friends were not only running against Democratic challengers. They were carrying the weight of a national party, and a president, whose decisions they did not always control.
And that may be the hardest part of this election for me to accept.
Algenon Cash is a nationally recognized speaker and the managing director of Wharton Gladden & Company, an investment banking firm.