undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
As Development Fund Faces Scrutiny, Dunseith Grant Questions Resurface
By K.L. Collom,
2026-09-25New reporting about the North Dakota Development Fund has brought renewed attention to questions The Dakotan raised last year about state-supported projects involving Packet Digital and Chiptronics at the Dunseith factory site and question’s about their operating capabilities.
Since our May 29, 2025 article, the Industrial Commission has provided an answer on the grants: Packet Digital satisfied its contractual deliverables and reporting requirements. The Commission also clarified that job creation was not a required deliverable.
The Original Questions
Our reporting examined two $500,000 grants announced for Packet Digital in 2017 and another $500,000 grant approved in 2019, with Chiptronics identified as a project partner.
One Packet Digital application linked in our original report also disclosed a broader history of state-backed financing and incentives that the article did not individually itemize. Packet Digital listed a $500,000 NDDF revolving working-capital line available from 2006 until it was paid off in February 2021; a $999,999 preferred-equity investment through NDDF and the Bank of North Dakota’s New Venture Fund, for which the company reported $300,000 in accrued dividends paid and a remaining balance of $957,925 at the time of the application; a $200,000 Bank of North Dakota PACE interest-rate buydown for a Fargo property; and a second PACE buydown then expected to begin in January 2024. The application also listed $1.225 million across three Solar Soaring phases and $1 million across two Portable Solar Array phases, with matching support connected to the Naval Research Laboratory, U.S. Marine Corps, a Department of Defense contractor and the Office of the Secretary of Defense.
Those disclosures describe Packet Digital’s broader use of state-backed financing and were not necessarily all connected to Chiptronics or the Dunseith facility, which was the focus of our first report on this.
The 2019 materials described electronics-manufacturing capabilities and a Class 100,000 clean room. The project was also presented with an expectation of 93 jobs at Chiptronics in Dunseith.
A former Benchmark employee told The Dakotan that the clean room had been removed before 2017. The Dakotan also found out that the total jobs created was likely in the single digits.
Records reviewed for the article also raised questions about equipment use and the factory’s occupancy during the project period, including a lease to Safeguard Armor Solutions and subsequent eviction proceedings against the company.
A January 2021 Commerce property description provided to Charles Hoefer, who was being recruited to redevelop the factory for RV manufacturing, identified Benchmark as the last known tenant. It omitted Chiptronics and Safeguard Armor Solutions. The basis for that description also remains relevant to understanding what the state told the incoming business owner.
What the Industrial Commission Said
A few weeks after the original article, Industrial Commission Executive Director Karen Tyler responded to The Dakotan following a review of Renewable Energy Program grants to Packet Digital.
Tyler described a process involving staff screening, independent technical reviewers, an advisory board or council, and final approval by the Industrial Commission. Contracts establish deliverables, deadlines and reporting requirements, with qualifying expenses reimbursed after the requirements for each reporting period are met.
She also said subcontractor relationships require Commission approval, while the contractor remains responsible for its subcontractors’ performance.
On employment, Tyler wrote:
“In regard to representations about jobs creation by both Contractor Packet Digital and subcontractor Chiptronics, while certainly a desired outcome, jobs creation was not a specified deliverable for Contractor Packet Digital.”
She continued:
“The Contractor, Packet Digital, satisfied all deliverables and reporting requirements of its contracts and the contracts were closed in May of 2019 and January of 2021 after final reports were received.”
The Commission’s position is that Packet Digital completed the work its contracts required. A shortfall in projected jobs would not, by itself, establish a violation of those contracts.
What the New Reporting Adds
The Bismarck Tribune’s reporting on NDDF transactions describes inadequate conflict disclosures and approximately $3.96 million in transactions involving five entities connected to two board members.
The Tribune also identifies a historical $500,000 convertible note involving Packet Digital while Terri Zimmerman held roles with the company and NDDF. Commerce said Zimmerman recused herself from the relevant decisions.
That note is separate from the Industrial Commission grants. The reporting does not identify every entity in the audit findings or establish that any of the grants previously examined were awarded improperly.
Eide Bailly’s financial-statement audit also identifies a material weakness in NDDF’s board conflict-of-interest controls, citing a vague disclosure form and insufficient understanding of related-party reporting.
These developments reinforce the importance of documenting relationships and verifying representations before committing public money. Their relevance to the earlier grants is a reason to examine the record, rather than a conclusion about what that record will show.
The new reporting also adds evidence concerning Hoefer’s dealings with the state. The Tribune independently found his confidential financial documents and communications in Commerce responses to media records requests in 2024 and 2025. Hoefer has since filed a federal civil-rights lawsuit against current and former Commerce and NDDF officials. Commerce declined to discuss Hoefer’s claims with the Tribune, citing pending litigation.
The governor’s office also cited pending litigation when it declined to comment on whether Gov. Kelly Armstrong would support an independent investigation.
The Industrial Commission’s position is that Packet Digital completed the work required under its contracts. The remaining questions concern how the manufacturing capabilities and employment projections presented with the projects were evaluated, not whether those projections were legally binding contract requirements.
That is where the public record stands today: the contracts were deemed complete, the projected jobs were not required deliverables, and the broader NDDF findings have renewed scrutiny without resolving the specific questions surrounding the former Dunseith projects or the future of the fund itself.