undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
North Port City Commission OKs changes regarding development NDAs
By Staff Writer,
10 hours agoCommissioner Oleg Lisitsyn seconded a motion made by Vice Mayor Demetrius Petrow to make changes to how nondisclosure agreements are handled in North Port on Tuesday evening. The motion passed unanimously.
NORTH PORT — While the city of North Port can’t “do away” with nondisclosure agreements under state law, the City Commission voted Tuesday on a change that would require elected officials to be notified anytime a developer requests confidentiality.
NDAs recently left some North Port residents with a sour taste after a controversial data center was revealed to be under a confidentiality agreement earlier this year. Hundreds flocked to City Hall to speak out against allowing a data center. Many of those people were angry that the plans were not public.
Reacting to that, in September, commissioners voted to move toward getting rid of NDAs in the city.
Unfortunately for people who are skeptical about NDAs, that motion had a slim chance of standing up to state statutes.
Florida Statute 288.075 provides confidentiality protections for certain economic development information for a limited time. The statute states “business plans and site-location intentions submitted in writing prior to signing an incentive agreement are exempt from public records for 12 months — with a possible 12-month extension, excluding data centers — or for 180 days after a final project order is issued.”
In other words, while many in North Port and beyond may not like developer NDAs, there is little, if anything, that can be done to stop them in Florida.
Some, like residents Sharon Fay Arnold and Cassie Cordialini, believe NDAs can be abused or contradict Florida Sunshine Laws, which “guarantee the public’s right to access the meetings, deliberations, and proceedings of state and local government boards and commissions.”
“NDAs should be eliminated. Period,” Arnold said at a Tuesday evening commission meeting.
She believes in the case of the data center there were some “shenanigans” going on. She urged commissioners to use their power to scrap NDAs altogether.
Cordialini said it is crucial to have “accountability and transparency.”
“No to NDAs,” she said.
Others, including government officials, argue the rules allowing NDAs help business plans involving opening, moving or growing in a community. NDAs give firms time to study a project and decide if it is a good fit before sharing plans publicly.
COMMISSIONERS TO BE NOTIFIED
Commissioners discussed potential changes to the parts of the city rules they can control.
Vice Mayor Demetrius Petrow made a motion to advance a draft ordinance with an amendment requiring the commission to be notified whenever there is a request for a public-records disclosure exemption. New Commissioner Oleg Lisitsyn seconded the motion, which ultimately passed 5-0.
The ordinance stated the city is repealing the authority granted to the city manager, or a designee, on Feb. 4, 2021 to execute nondisclosure and confidentiality agreements related to economic development activities.
More details, including how commissioners will be notified, will be worked out at a later date, according to Julie Bellia, the interim city manager.
City Attorney Michael Fuino said that if commissioners are notified via email, the records of those emails will most likely not be public.
The other new commissioner, Elaine Allen-Emrich, asked if the City Commission would be allowed to tell anyone that they knew about an NDA.
Fuino said he wasn’t sure, as it’s an “unsettled area of law.”
Some opinions, he said, suggest that development NDAs are exempt from public records, but not from Sunshine Laws.
“(But) I don’t have an exact answer because no exact answer exists. It seems you can still talk about it,” Fuino said.