undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Punta Gorda

THE SCENE | Readers asked, we answered

By Sue Wade,

2026-03-09

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=0yRI88_19T9VsEw00

What one reader’s curious about, you’re probably curious about, too.

That’s when this columnist hunts for answers.

HOLDOVERS IN PGI

Q: Looks like the former Penny’s space in PGI is ready to open. Wonder what kind of menu it’ll have. — Linda Dobrian

A: Right, Linda, and sooner than you think. I just chatted with co-owner Kevin Leahy, who gives us the following scoop:

Even before Penny’s Diner and Speakeasy closed abruptly a year ago, the 4,800-square-foot Bal Harbor Plaza outparcel was clouded in controversy.

Work on its replacement started later in 2025, owners unknown, with a concept that shape-shifted from breakfast/lunch to sports bar to nightclub to school, depending on the spin of the daily rumor mill.

Dozens of noses have pressed against its glass, trying to sniff out the future.

The rumors (except the school one) have proved sort of true.

Kevin and Shauna Leahy, who launched Coastal Isles Wine Bar two years ago in the plaza, are about to open Holdover Café in the former Penny’s.

Its name is part in-joke, meaning “remainders of an earlier time” or even “tenants outstaying their lease,” but it also reflects the good vibes and late hours teased in its logo’s phrase “Brunch, Music, Memories.”

When they first opened Coastal Isles, the Leahys aimed to be the neighborhood “Cheers.” Soon they’ll have two of them.

Inspections permitting, Kevin hopes to open an 80-seat breakfast/lunch café from 7 a.m. to 2 p.m. on the former diner side, on March 16, before also rolling out a brand-new 65-seat sports bar, open from 4 p.m. until closing time, this summer. He’s busily interviewing for 25 new hires.

The remodel, Kevin says, is largely cosmetic, including repainting bright red, pink and blue walls a warm macadamia brown, evoking the comfort and relaxation appropriate for a café.

“They’d boarded up the speakeasy-side windows, so we took all that stuff down to brighten it up, and we put in a bunch of TVs,” Kevin said. “We’ve already had test-cooks of the menu at Cheney Brothers. It has 55 items, but we’ll pare it down to a manageable 20, plus weekly specials.”

The Leahys’ Coastal Isles has grown beyond just wine and tapas, now hosting comedy, trivia, Wine-O Bingo, murder mysteries, morning yoga and live music from local favorite Billy Fredericks and open-mic impresarios like Danny Beach, Souky and Andy Mauck. Eventually, that live music will move to a Holdover’s bar stage, while the wine bar focuses on comedy.

Kevin sees parlaying Holdover’s full food menu with the wine bar’s comedy and events right across the parking lot.

“We want to treat locals well, too, so there’s going to be a rewards program and summer specials to keep them coming in.”

Originally from Ohio, the Leahys moved to Florida five years ago, at which point Kevin intended to retire from an IT consulting career, while Shauna continued to work as a radiation therapist.

Kevin explained, “We have 10-year-old twin girls at home, so I’m only semi-retired. But now I get to do stuff that’s more fun.”

WHEN’S A QUARTER-POUNDER NOT A QUARTER-POUNDER?

Q1: I like a good burger as well as the next person, but there doesn’t seem to be one restaurant here that offers anything but a half-pound burger. I don’t believe I’m the only person who can’t eat a half-pound of meat, toppings and a bun in one sitting. Of all the leftovers I might want to reheat and finish later, a burger isn’t one of them. I’m hoping you might drop a suggestion for places to have a 4-ounce burger on their menus. — Jim & Sandy Russell

A1: Jim and Sandy, you’re preaching to the wrong choir.

I personally don’t want anything less than a big, fat, greasy, half-pound burger when I eat out, and I don’t mind the leftovers. I even get annoyed when they split one in two and squoosh two quarter-pounders together into a smashburger.

You can find a quarter-pounder at Burger King, McDonald’s, Wendy’s, Checkers, Culver’s and Five Guys, but I doubt that’s what you’re looking for.

Even those aren’t quarter-pounders after cooking. Shrinkage amounts to 25% of your average burger, so all you’ll get is 3 ounces of meat.

Is that really all you want?

In case it is, I’ve asked around among my burger-flipping buddies.

You can order a single smashburger (one-quarter pound at Burg’r Bar, Hometown Grill and Kings Roadhouse) or a trio of sliders to share at Burg’r Bar.

Beef ‘O’ Brady’s has a $10.99+ meal menu including a patty melt with a 6-ounce burger, which renders down to a quarter-pound when cooked.

Sam’s Subs and Soup starts out with a 6.7-ounce patty, fresh not frozen, and smashes it themselves, but I can tell you from experience, it’s a two-meal burger.

It might be too much meat for you, but Chili’s offers a Big QP, boasting two slices of American cheese, mustard, ketchup, pickles, diced onions and 85% more beef than a Quarter Pounder with Cheese. They work this wonder by using a precooked patty of 7.5 ounces. (By now you know that amounts to 5.6 ounces of cooked meat. In other words, it’s almost twice the cooked weight of a quarter-pounder.)

Q2: You’re correct that I’m not talking about the chains. I’m thinking of some of the mouthwatering combinations at the Twisted Fork and Paradise Grill in Nokomis. Burgers are like pizza — to really savor the experience you have to pick it up and bite into it to get all flavors exploding at the first taste. Ah well, in a few months, I’ll savor the smaller option at Wegmans Burger Bar — with all the toppings. — Jim & Sandy Russell

A2: Right! Wegmans Burger Bars in New York State offer both the really-3-ounce quarter-pounder for as little as $7, and 6-ouncers that render down to one-quarter for as little as $10.

Q: Is there a website for foodies to look for restaurants in Charlotte County? I’ve tried online and come up with some but not all. My friend and I go out to eat every week and go to a different place each time. — Dean Hart

A: Aside from TripAdvisor and Yelp, there are a bunch on Facebook, Dean. The largest and best run: Mark Rosen and Troy Conner‘s 12-year-old, 62,000-member Gulf Coast Restaurant and Dining Review; Len Martire‘s 10-year-old, 45,000-member Charlotte County Eats; and Wanda Lopez‘ 11-year-old, 24,400-member SWFL Foodies.

Comments