undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Request raises concerns about commercial development near Tucker, Baytree
By Ginger Livingston,
2026-08-20Concerns that rezoning for a childcare facility on Red Banks Road could lead to commercial development and the loss of a wooded area near the Tucker Estates and Baytree neighborhoods prompted city officials to recommend denying the request.
MMT Management LLC on Tuesday asked Greenville’s Planning and Zoning Commission to rezone about 5 acres southeast of E.B. Aycock Middle School currently owned by Oakmont Baptist Church.
Planning board members urged the company’s representative to talk with property owners to see if a compromise can be reached. The Greenville City Council can overturn the recommended denial.
The property is made up of two parcels. One includes a building that was a church and a music school, which Oakmont has used for its ministries. The other property is a combination of vacant space and a wooded area.
Both are zoned for residential uses: One is R15S and the other is R9S. Chantae Gooby, assistant planning director, said the two single-family residential zones are among the most restrictive in the city. However, churches are allowed.
MMT Management wants both properties rezoned for office because childcare facilities can be located in office zoning. The facilities can also be located in R15S zoning districts if a special use permit is obtained.
The company operates a childcare facility on Old Tar Road, said Byron Aynes of The Overton Group, which represented MMT. The business has to relocate because the building is being removed as part of the Old Tar Road/Evans Street widening project.
“It’s been a challenge to find suitable land for their use, a building that is affordable, that allows the daycare facility to offer the services they do at the prices they do,” Aynes said. The Red Banks Road building is the perfect location.
Aynes said 175 families are served by the childcare facility but didn’t know how many children attended the facility.
Board member Allen Thomas asked if mobile units could be added to the location.
Gooby said modular construction would be allowed, but Aynes said that isn’t the owners’ intent.
No one else spoke in favor of the request, but residents from the adjacent Baytree and Tucker Estates neighborhoods spoke against the plan.
“It’s one of the few green spaces still left in the town,” Bill Twine said. The city should preserve some green spaces.
“This is a treed area, a little game area, we have fox, we have owls … we have hawks we’ve seen back there,” Twine said.
Twine said there isn’t any commercial property along Red Banks Road between 14th Street and Charles Boulevard, so the rezoning request doesn’t fit in the neighborhood.
In other residential areas, once a business goes in, other housing lots become commercial spaces and the residential character is lost, Twine said.
Aynes said The Memorial Baptist Church nearby operates a childcare program, so it’s a service already offered in the area.
Hannah Collins, no relation to board chairman John Collins, said her neighborhood is one of the few places where children still play together outside. They also cut through the property in question to reach E.B. Aycock.
“It’s nice to still see kids getting out and doing stuff like that,” Hannah Collins said.
If the rezoning was only for the building, which fronts Red Banks Road, she wouldn’t be opposed. Her concern is the rezoning of the vacant lot and what could go there.
It could be a safety problem for Aycock, because a crosswalk with a crossing guard is near the location, Collins said.
Art Graepel asked the planning and zoning board to visit the location before making a decision. John Collins said the board had to vote Tuesday night.
Michelle Woodlief said she doesn’t believe the building has enough space to house a childcare facility.
“It may sound nice to have children in the building, (but) they are going to need more space,” Woodlief said.
Aynes said the organization’s existing building is 8,000 square feet and the building in question is slightly more than 10,000 square feet.
Board member Brad Carter said the R15S rezoning allows childcare facilities with a special use permit. Office zoning allows for childcare facilities along with other types of development, he said.
“If they are not planning to build out, it’s fine the way it is,” Carter said.
Gooby said it’s her understanding that if MMT leases or buys the property, they would take on a piece of property that isn’t useful to them without the rezoning.
Aynes said the sellers don’t want to sell only one parcel.
Board member Thomas Remington asked if the R9S parcel could be rezoned R15S, which would allow childcare operations.
Gooby said it could work. She reminded the board that state statute requires the planning board take action within 30 days of the application being presented. If the board takes no action, the request will still go to council without its recommendation.
Aynes said he would need to discuss pursuing a special use permit with the applicant.
Carter said it appears there is a 30-foot gas easement running through the property that likely has use limitations.
“I’m wondering if there could be a meeting of the minds … preserving that as perpetual green space and not using the back of that parcel, which is all existing wooded area,” Carter said.
Gooby said she didn’t know if there are any encumbrances associated with the gas easement.
Remington recommended rezoning the R9S property to R15S, which would allow the childcare facility.
After additional discussion, the board unanimously voted to recommend denial of the office rezoning.