undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Elizabeth City

Council tables costly firefighter schedule change

By Christian Marnon,

14 days ago

A growing trend among regional fire departments to shorten firefighters’ workweeks by restructuring shifts has Elizabeth City Fire Chief Chris Carver concerned.

Fire departments in Norfolk, Virginia Beach, Greenville and other area cities have moved to a 24/72 schedule, or 24 hours on duty followed by 72 hours off, according to Carver.

The change would reduce the average firefighter’s workweek from 56 hours to 42 by moving from three shifts to four. If Elizabeth City doesn’t adopt a similar schedule, Carver worries a department already struggling with recruitment and retention could lose more firefighters over time.

Making the switch, however, would take several years and cost the city more than $1 million. Several Elizabeth City Council members said that money may not be available, given the city is also considering a new $12 million fire station.

Carver pitched the plan to the council during an Oct. 26 work session. He acknowledged it was a “big ask” but said a number of firefighters had asked him to bring it to the city for preliminary consideration.

“My guys asked me to bring this to your attention,” he said. “Their concern, along with mine, is recruitment and retention. It’s already hard out there now to recruit and retain personnel, especially when you’re competing with a schedule like this. It’s a big ask because you’re adding an extra shift to the department.

It’s got a hefty price tag that comes with it, [and] it takes three to four years to implement.”

Recruitment and retention problems, he added, are directly tied to ongoing concerns about firefighters’ mental health and family time.

“[Recent studies show] the average firefighter is [experiencing] more medical problems due to sleep deprivation, mental health issues [and] family issues, and that’s why people aren’t staying in the fire service,” Carver said.

He cited a statistic showing that a firefighter who works 56 hours a week for 30 years puts in an estimated 87,360 hours, compared with an estimated 62,400 hours for an employee who works 40 hours a week over the same period. That amounts to about 9.6 more years of work, not counting mandatory overtime.

Carver said firefighters rarely get weekends with their families because of the schedule, a frequent complaint.

Several council members expressed sympathy for the proposal but said they couldn’t give a definite answer without further reviewing the city’s finances.

“I don’t think we can look at this in isolation from everything else,” said Councilman Joseph Peel. “We’re looking at $15 to $18 million by [the] time we build [the] station, man it, have equipment in place, and then this maybe on top [of] or part of it. It’s not a flat no, but my recommendation [is] we table it until we come back with more information.”

Earlier in the discussion, Carver said the department might be able to offset the cost by applying for a Staffing for Adequate Fire and Emergency Response, or SAFER, grant through the Federal Emergency Management Agency when applications open in spring 2027.

“[SAFER] would cover the cost of firefighters for three years, 100%,” he said. “At least that’s what they did last year; it changes each year. That would at least help absorb some of the cost.”

City Manager Reginald Goodson said he meets with Carver monthly for fire department updates and that the main goal of the pitch was to start a discussion about retention.

“What we wanted to do was to get it before you and [show] how it could affect our fire department in the future,” Goodson said. “We may lose firefighters if we can’t go to this schedule while others in our area [are implementing] it.”

Comments