undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Oregon

Recent crash highlights e-bike, scooter concerns

By DAVID PATCH,

9 hours ago

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=0l9O4w_1H85ciD600

When Ryan Gombash started working in emergency rooms a decade ago, he didn’t know what an e-bike was.

Now, he said during a break from his shift on Friday at ProMedica Bay Park Community Hospital in Oregon, he treats about one case per week of someone injured while riding an e-bike or electric scooter.

At Bay Park, those typically are relatively minor injuries, up to broken wrists or collarbones, Dr. Gombash said.

“At [ProMedica] Toledo Hospital, every other week they’re calling out a major trauma level on an e-bike,” he said.

The most serious cases usually involve collisions with motor vehicles, Dr. Gombash said, and that was the case with a Nov. 5 crash that seriously injured a 15-year-old girl on Eleanor Avenue.

A preliminary crash report stated a scooter operated by Bryanna McCourt, of the 1800 block of Giant Street, was traveling east along the curb in the 1500 block of Eleanor about 3:14 p.m. when it veered to the left in front of a car driven by Daja Miller, 27, of the 1200 block of Higley Avenue.

The crash occurred in a 25-mph zone, but the report did not provide a speed estimate for Ms. Miller’s vehicle.

The report describes Miss McCourt as the at-fault participant. It also lists her as a “pedestrian/skater,” apparently because Ohio’s standard crash-report form does not offer “e-scooter” or “e-bike” as a reporting option.

Bicycles are among the options, as are “other” motorist and “other nonmotorist.” That leaves it up to the reporting police officer’s discretion as to how to characterize the rider’s vehicle.

Statistics consequently aren’t available for electric scooter or electric bicycle crashes or injuries. But Dr. Gombash said scooter and e-bike injuries surged during the summer of 2025.

And with the speeds involved — often 20 mph, some faster — the more serious injuries are similar to those motorcyclists suffer when they crash, rather than those for bicyclists, the doctor said.

Anthony Hall, a Sylvania-based partner with the Kisling, Nestico & Redick personal-injury law firm, said “pretty alarming” statistics from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission show 60,000 emergency-room visits relating to electric scooters and bicycles occurred during 2024, compared to just 751 in 2017.

The same data showed 94 fatal accidents in 2024, Mr. Hall said.

He and Sgt. Mohamad Nasser, a spokesman for the Toledo Police Department, both said the proliferation of e-scooters and e-bikes only elevates the importance of drivers and riders paying attention to each other and operating their vehicles safely.

“We don’t want to see anyone else hurt,” Sgt. Nasser said. “That means a little more consideration and awareness for everyone. The best thing we can do is pay attention.”

Assess children’s capabilities

Experts said parents need to give careful thought to allowing their children to ride such vehicles and to ensure they wear proper protective gear if they do.

“Train them to be an alert operator of these things,” Mr. Hall said.

The most important thing youthful operators need to recognize, Sgt. Nasser said, is that when they get out onto public streets, they’re in an environment with vehicles much bigger than them.

Ohio assigns electric scooters and bicycles to several regulatory classes, depending on their top speeds. Class 1 and 2 equipment may provide power only up to 20 mph, while Class 3 e-bikes may provide power assistance up to 28 mph.

No one under age 16 may ride a Class 3 e-bike, and all must wear helmets. But even in that case, no license, registration, or operator training is required.

Until now, Mr. Hall said, anyone operating any motorized vehicle capable of such speed must prove reasonable competence to venture onto public roadways. But with e-bikes and e-scooters, that hurdle is no longer required.

Both drivers and riders can err

When car drivers are at fault for collisions with e-bikes and e-scooters, it’s often because they did not distinguish them at a distance from their unmotorized counterparts and misjudged their speed, Mr. Hall said.

“We want to tell drivers, be alert and aware,” the lawyer said. “They’re easy to misidentify. Train yourself to be more careful.”

E-scooter and e-bike operators, meanwhile, are more likely to crash because of reckless operation, he said.

“Stricter laws on these are necessary,” he said before noting he would not allow his teenage children to ride one and persuaded his mother against buying e-bikes for his nephews.

“They can be a wonderful tool for transportation, especially for people who otherwise cannot afford it,” Mr. Hall said. “But a regular pedal bicycle can be useful for many of the same purposes, and it’s safer.”

Sgt. Nasser predicted, however, that the electric versions’ popularity will only grow because of their convenience and utility.

E-scooter and e-bike riders “are obligated to follow those traffic laws for their safety and the safety of others,” the sergeant said. “You have to stay alert, following the laws and obeying signs and signals.”

Proper gear and insurance

Dr. Gombash said he hasn’t had a patient die from an e-bike or scooter crash, but colleagues have.

He said he wouldn’t recommend anyone under age 16 ride any e-scooter or e-bike and cautioned that conventional bike helmets aren’t robust enough for safety on these faster-moving vehicles.

Helmets designed for riding motorcycles are more appropriate, he said, and riders also should wear protective clothing similar to what a motorcyclist would wear as protection against road rash in an accident.

Mr. Hall urged anyone operating an e-bike or scooter — or their parents — to obtain specific insurance. Traditional auto polices and homeowner’s insurance don’t cover these accidents, he said, but specialty coverage is available.

“Purchase as much as you can get and you can afford, because it’s usually pretty cheap,” the attorney said. “Even with minor injuries, the money goes quick.”

emoji_like
2

Comments