undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Bill seeks to balance repeat gun violence with Second Amendment
By JIM PROVANCE / BLADE COLUMBUS BUREAU CHIEF,
2025-05-21COLUMBUS — The Ohio House of Representatives on Wednesday voted 71-24 for a bill that attempts to straddle the line between cracking down on gun-wielding repeat offenders and allowing some a chance to eventually regain their right to own a firearm.
The bill passed over the reservations of some law enforcement entities.
”It is true this is the largest increase in criminal penalties that we’ve seen in the state of Ohio since 1996, when we had ‘truth in sentencing.’ Absolutely, it is,” said Rep Josh Williams (R., Sylvania Township), a bill sponsor.
“But it is a surgical scalpel,” he said. “It only targets felons who have been previously convicted of a violent felony, and then they have been caught with a firearm in our community.”
House Bill 5 generally increases penalties and imposes mandatory minimum prison sentences for those who continue to commit crimes with guns after they’ve already been prohibited via court order from possessing them.
But the would-be Repeat Offender Act won the backing of gun-rights advocates for provisions that would make it easier for rehabilitated offenders to have their convictions expunged so the records don’t show up in gun dealer background checks.
“...Importantly, the legislation does not alter any existing gun laws that affect our law-abiding gun owners,” said Rep. Bernie Willis (R., Springfield), the bill’s other sponsor.
The bill won bipartisan support, but all the negative votes came from Democrats. They included the three representing Toledo.
“We are flooding communities with illegal weapons through gun shows and the ability to buy guns online,” Rep. Dani Isaacsohn (D., Cincinnati) said. “We are injuring law enforcement’s ability to take those guns off the streets when they’re begging us to let them do a better job of law enforcement. That’s what works to make our communities safer.”
He also urged his colleagues not to tie the hands of judges when it comes to sentencing decisions.
“This bill is riddled with mandatory minimums,” Mr. Isaacsohn said.
Heinz Von Eckartsberg, retired Dublin police chief, testified before the House Judiciary Committee on behalf of the Ohio Association of Chiefs of Police earlier in the day.
The association opposes the bill because, in part, it bars the state Bureau of Criminal Investigation from maintaining expunged records for the sole purpose of background checks for police officer hiring.
"This change would severely hinder our ability to ensure only individuals of the highest integrity are entrusted with the responsibility and authority inherent with the position of law enforcement officer," he said. "Law enforcement must and should have access to a police candidate's complete criminal history, including expunged records, to make fully informed hiring decisions.’
Mr. Williams, however, said federal law regarding the restoration of Second Amendment rights prohibits keeping expunged records for any purpose.
Mr. Von Eckartsberg also objected to a separate provision that would reduce felony penalties for some other crimes involving "weapons under disability." That, he said, would be “counter-productive" and send the “wrong message."
The Fraternal Order of Police of Ohio previously opposed the bill, arguing some provisions would make it harder for police to do their jobs. But lobbyist Mike Weinman said Wednesday that the FOP is now reviewing the last-minute changes that were negotiated by Mr. Williams.
The Ohio Prosecuting Attorneys Association dropped its opposition after the committee removed language to automatically require expungement for those deemed eligible.
"If we're sealing without applying or showing up, you could be including people who are still engaged in criminal activity," Executive Director Louis Tobin said.
The bill now requires courts to send letters to those who are eligible, but past offenders would still have to apply and appear at hearings.
Mr. Williams said negotiations will continue even as the bill moves to the Senate.