undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Surprise mayoral candidate investigated for removing sign
By Jason Stone Mail,
2024-05-07Surprise City Councilmember Aly Cline and challenger Kevin Sartor staged their first mayoral candidate forum for the Northwest Valley Regional Chamber of Commerce last week.
But it turns out Cline is battling more than one opponent in this year’s election: Maricopa County prosecutors.
The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office has under review a complaint a Surprise city activist made after Cline admitted on video in March she removed a sign promoting her election opponent that was affixed to a handicapped parking sign pole.
“I took down one sign that was on city property and turned it into code enforcement,” Cline said, adding the sign was placed “inappropriately.”
City officials agree with Cline the sign was illegally placed, but the person who put the sign there, north Surprise resident Rebekah Massie, claims Cline illegally removed her questionable sign and violated her First Amendment rights because the sign was promoting Sartor’s petition to get on the ballot for the mayoral election.
“My intent was not to prejudice anyone about anything,” Cline said. “My focus was to share this papering of city property with inappropriate items.”
Massie filed a police complaint two days after the sign’s removal, but Surprise Police passed the case on to the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office because of what a city spokesperson called a “conflict of interest.”
Karla Navarette, the public information officer for the County Attorney’s Office, said Cline’s case will be adjudicated in the order it was received. Navarette said Cline is charged with theft and the case is still “under review.”
It’s unclear if it will be decided before the July 30 primary election.
“I’m a pretty law-abiding person who has never had a problem in the past,” Cline said about the case.
City Manager Bob Wingenroth, while declining comment on Cline’s actions specifically, said the city would prefer residents contact code enforcement to deal with signs that may be illegally placed across the city.
“There is a process a person can take: contact the prosecutors office and file a complaint or go to the police office and file a complaint,” Wingenroth said. “The best thing would be for you to call code enforcement and you kind of turn it over to them.”
The confrontation between Cline and Massie happened on March 27, a day before the State of the City event at City Hall. Massie happened to be putting up the signs on poles across the City Center when Cline drove up for her work with Friends of the Surprise Libraries.
Cline, who has a handicapped placard hanging from her vehicle’s mirror, parked in the spot Massie where put the sign up. Cline got out of the car and removed it. That’s when Massie, who was still nearby taking photos of Cline, began videotaping the city council member and confronted her.
“I sort of felt set up,” Cline said. “It’s like she was waiting for me at the library.”
Massie said she just happened to be in the right place at the right time.
“Obviously, it could be concerning,” Cline said. “I’m concerned I didn’t follow the letter of the law. That's always a concern.”
The city’s sign code has a section for temporary signs, or ones not intended for permanent display. The code clearly defines areas where any sign is disallowed, including trees, utility poles, public benches, or any other form of public property.
It also details what signs are prohibited signs: abandoned signs, pole signs of a permanent nature, snipe signs and median signs.
When the city finds what it deems an illegal sign, it has a process for notifying the person or group who put it up, as it did in the case with Massie.
Massie first got the attention of the city when she began putting up signs in the areas of Asante Park and Library late last year to promote a community meeting from Councilmember Nick Haney concerning traffic problems in north Surprise. Massie runs a website called The Grand Failure, which details traffic issues near Grand and 163rd avenues.
“I respectfully request that you remove them,” Wingenroth wrote in an email to Massie. The city manager wrote if Massie didn’t take them down, the city would hold on to the signs for her to come pick up for two weeks.
For the Sartor signs around City Center, the city sent Massie a certified letter to alert her to remove the signs, but Massie rejected the letter, she said, because she felt the signs were legally placed.
“The fact that the city allows certain signs to be erected and is targeting mine and my organization’s signs is a blatant First Amendment violation and renders any judgment, accusation, or removal of said signs as unconstitutional,” Massie wrote in her email to Wingenroth.
Later she wrote: “Please note that if the city decides to remove the signs, I will be forced to take any and all avenues to pursue what are my legal rights, including legal actions.”
Wingenroth, who said he hasn’t viewed the video Massie shot of Cline, said Massie’s signs were illegally placed based on Section 109 of the city code, adding the one Cline took down shouldn’t have been there.
“Her viewpoint is it’s freedom of speech, and the city’s viewpoint is this is not freedom of speech,” Cline said.
Wingenroth said city staff are taking down illegal signs across the city every day on rounds.
“When they do maintenance on the park, any signs put up on light poles, they just take them down,” Wingenroth said. “It’s just a matter of procedure that they do it.”
However, Massie sent Wingenroth examples of temporary signs attached to light poles and power poles across the city that nobody has removed.
“The (city) council does not predict all the various things that could happen,” Wingenroth said about the city sign codes. “There isn’t a provision in the sign code that provides for a process if somebody takes down a sign that you can’t put up. It does not foresee that.”
Cline said she is unsure if the matter will help Sartor’s campaign for mayor. Cline has been a city councilmember since 2020.
“My focus is what I’ve done for the city and what I will do for the city more than comparing Kevin and I to each other,” Cline said.
To report a questionable sign across the city, residents can call Code Enforcement at 623-222-3013, or email codeenforcement@surpriseaz.gov.
Jason Stone can be reached at jstone@iniusa.org. We’d like to invite our readers to submit their civil comments, pro or con, on this issue. Email AZOpinions@iniusa.org.
Jason Stone
Former NAU Lumberjack who loves going to concerts (or I did), watching sports (or I did) and hanging out with friends (oh, never mind). I also enjoy backgammon, surfing and men who are not afraid to cry.