undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Scottsdale

Scottsdale settles lawsuit for $78,000

2023-05-04

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=017p0k_0mDsGqss00

The City of Scottsdale is settling a lawsuit with a man who claims to have tripped on a sidewalk panel and fell for $78,000.

The city council approved the settlement as part of it’s consent agenda May 2.

Had the settlement not been approved, the cost to the city to litigate the case would be in excess of $50,000, according to a staff report.

John Fountain brought a lawsuit against the city after falling over a sidewalk panel that was raised and pushed up from the rest of the sidewalk. Fountain alleged that he suffered injuries including a broken right arm, a sinus fracture as well as shoulder, facial and head trauma and pain. Fountain claims medical bills totaling $37,514, according to a staff report.

Fountain had originally demanded $300,000 to settle the claim but city attorneys were able to negotiation that down to $78,000.

“The City has asserted the defenses that this condition was open and obvious, the City had no notice of any dangerous condition in the path, the plaintiff was partially at fault for his fall and his damages have been exaggerated,” a staff report said.

The city had retained a professional engineer to rebut Fountain’s claim, but has been hamstringed because it repaired the sidewalk tile before the suit was filed.

“The City has been disadvantaged in this case by having limited information about the sidewalk’ s condition prior to the time of Mr. Fountain’s fall,” a staff report stated.

emoji_like
5

Comments / 1