undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN

City Council considering raising utility rates

By J. Graber Mail,

2023-03-08

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=1ZYrEL_0lCO08LI00

Scottsdale’s utility rates are likely to go up — again.

The Scottsdale City Council heard proposals from staff to increase water, sewer and solid waste rates during its regularly scheduled meeting March 7, though it is not scheduled to vote on the proposed changes until May 16.

The council members gave no indication on where they stand on the proposed increases, as no one spoke during the presentation.

However, Mayor David Ortega told the Daily Independent that he supports the rate hikes.

“Yes, at first glance, increases reflect costs of raw water and treatment processing,” he said.

If council does approve the proposed increases, it would be the fifth time in six years that water and sewer rates will have gone up.

Scottsdale Water Department spokeswoman Valerie Schneider told the Daily Independent that the goal is to have small, incremental increases annually rather than skipping years and having large increases.

It would also be at least the second time in two years solid waste rates have gone up.

Water and sewer

If approved, the water rate increase would take effect Nov. 1 of this year and is expected to bump water operations revenue 4.2%, while the sewer rate increase would go into effect July 1 and would jump sewer operations revenue by 5.8%.

How much the rate increases will effect residents depends on a number of variables.

The base rate for water service is proposed to go up between 50 cents for a customer with a 5/8-inch meter to $17.50 for those with the maximum, 8-inch meter.

For the average resident, with a 1-inch meter, the base rate will go up 90 cents to $27.55 per month.

Then there’s the cost for the actual water. That too is on a scale ranging from $1.65 per thousand gallons used for those using less than 5,000 gallons per month to $7.05 per 1,000 gallons for residents using more than 30,000 gallons per month.

Staff is also proposing shrinking the tier sizes to push higher water use into more expensive brackets.

“Given today’s environment, that’s actually a good thing to encourage folks to save water,” Brian Biesemeyer, Scottsdale Water executive director said.

On the sewer side, the proposed rate for a single family home would go from $2.71 per month to $2.82 per month. The top tier for sewer costs is for restaurants and bakeries, which would jump from $5.83 to $6.07.

“They have a higher strength returning to us in fats and oil and greases and it’s just more difficult to treat,” Biesemeyer said.

The proposed rates would leave Scottsdale in the middle of the pack of other Valley cities for cost of water and sewer.

For a resident with a 1-inch meter using 16,000 gallons per month and returning 11,000 gallons, Scottsdale would be more expensive than Peoria, Gilbert and Chandler but less expensive than Tempe, Phoenix, Mesa and Glendale, according to city records.

There are a number of factors driving up the cost of water for city customers. The cost of raw water from the Central Arizona Project water is going up 27% and water from the Salt River Project is increasing 10%. There are also increased actions required for drought preparedness, such as an increased conservation budget, increased staffing (for conservation and compliance), increased operating costs at the Chaparral water treatment plant and increased groundwater treatment costs.
Increases in sewer rates stem from something else.

“We are developing more sewer assets to recycle our water,” Biesemeyer said. “That’s the additional cost. There are both costs in an additional pump back or lift station to pump more water up to our campus as well as expansion on the reclamation side of that campus to make sure we can treat that water we pump up.”

Solid waste

The effect of proposed rate increases on customers’ bills for solid waste is a little simpler.

For residents, the cost for collections from a first and second can would go up 8%.

For commercial users, the rates would go up 5% across the board.
What’s more is the rates for residents and commercial users are scheduled to go up 5% each for the next four years after this increase.
The main reasons for the proposed increases are landfill fees, recycling fees, transfer fees and fleet increases.

The second largest reason for the proposed jump are related to personnel costs, including five new positions, grade changes for employees, benefits and overtime.

Scottsdale Solid Waste Director Dave Bennett said the reason the residential is going up more than commercial is because the new positions would serve the residential side of the operation, which also accounts for the bulk of material headed to the landfill.

With the increases, Scottsdale would remain in the middle of the pack when comparing rates with other cities in the Valley. That makes Scottsdale more expensive than Peoria, Chandler and Glendale but cheaper than Tempe, Mesa and Phoenix, according to city records.

Bennett did have some good news to share with the council too though.

In 2019 the recycling center at the Salt River Landfill was lost to a fire but a brand new, state of the art one is due to open June 1. That will considerably lower the processing costs.

The new facility also includes a 400,000 gallon water tank on site.

“If this facility was ever to experience a fire on the magnitude that happened in 2019, that tank would help with water supply to combat that fire,” Bennett said.

Also, after running very behind in the brush and bulk material pick up program last year, the schedule was kept on pace this year.

“Additional tractors helped increase productivity and retain staff,” Bennett said.

J. Graber can be reached at jgraber@iniusa.org. We like to invite our readers to submit their civil comments pro or con on this issue. Email AZOpinions@iniusa.org.

emoji_like
3

Comments