undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
What to learn from Brassfield Elementary parents' success in blocking a cell tower
By T. Keung Hui,
21 hours agoA 185-foot cell tower will not rise on the campus of Brassfield Elementary School in Raleigh after parents and neighbors applied steady pressure from multiple directions that moved the school board.
The Wake County school board voted 6-3 to reject a lease that would have put a Verizon tower on an unused portion of Brassfield’s campus, The News & Observer reported. The deal would have paid the district $30,000 a year to start, with potential earnings of $1.5 million over 25 years if other wireless carriers signed on.
It’s a sign of what could happen at the three remaining schools still being studied for towers — East Millbrook Middle in Raleigh, Fox Road Elementary in Raleigh and Hodge Road Elementary in Knightdale.
The Brassfield playbook
When APC-EDGE, the Raleigh-based partnership that holds an exclusive 10-year contract with Wake schools to market and develop new cell tower sites, brought the Brassfield deal forward, the response was not a single angry email. It was layered.
Neighbors spoke first.Five residents addressed the board in early October, raising concerns about health risks from radio frequency radiation, dropping property values and the visual impact of a nearly 200-foot tower in a residential area near Falls Lake. Janine Jannicelli, a multiple cancer survivor who lives near the school, asked the board directly: “Is $30,000 a year worth taking even an uncertain risk with hundreds of children when another location may be available?”
Parents joined the second wave. Two weeks later, Brassfield parents stood alongside the neighbors at the Oct. 20 meeting. That broader coalition — residents who cared about the neighborhood plus parents who cared about the school — was what the board cited when it voted 7-1 to table the lease and send it back to the facilities committee.
The PTA formalized the position. Brassfield’s PTA passed a resolution opposing the original plan. By the time APC Towers came back with a revised proposal — reducing the tower height by 10 feet, moving it 20 feet west and adding more shrubbery to hide it — the PTA’s opposition was on the record.
Parents kept showing up. When the board met for the final vote, PTA president Ellen Gowdy reframed the deal in terms of district risk rather than district revenue.
“It won’t make a dent in the budget deficit our district is facing,” Gowdy said. “A single lawsuit related to this tower could cost the district more than it will ever bring in. This is far too much risk for little reward.”
What moved the board
Board member Wing Ng, who represents the Brassfield area, laid out the reasoning that several of his colleagues echoed.
“Regardless of whether I feel this radio frequency is safe or not safe, I still have to understand, for my constituents, they do have concerns about it,” Ng said.
Board member Chris Heagarty was blunter about the math.
“I think the tower is safe,” Heagarty said. “But the bigger question is ultimately is it worth it to us, and is the damage to the school and the community, is that really offset by $15,000 or $30,000?”
Heagarty, Cheryl Caulfield, Lynn Edmonds, Christina Gordon, Jennifer Job and Ng voted against the tower. Vice chair Sam Hershey, Toshiba Rice and chair Tyler Swanson voted in favor.
Parent Stephanie Rockwell’s closing appeal captured what landed with the majority: “This board has an opportunity to get this right. You guys can stand up for Brassfield and for our children. Listen to the families that you represent.”
Where the three other schools stand
APC-EDGE — a partnership of APC Towers and Wireless EDGE — is still studying tower sites at East Millbrook Middle, Fox Road Elementary and Hodge Road Elementary. The company has not announced lease proposals for any of them, but the 2018 agreement with Wake gives it the exclusive right to pursue them.
Board member Jennifer Job made clear the Brassfield vote was not a blanket rejection of future towers.
“This doesn’t mean I’m going to vote against cell towers in the future,” Job said. “If we had the funding we needed, this wouldn’t even be a discussion.”
Wake already has cell towers at four schools, including one built at West Lake Elementary/West Lake Middle in Apex in 2021 that has raised nearly $148,000 so far. A 2024 agreement also authorized APC-EDGE to seek approval for a tower at Heritage Elementary/Heritage Middle in Wake Forest.
APC Towers argued throughout the Brassfield process that newer studies from the World Health Organization, the Journal of the National Cancer Institute and the Food and Drug Administration have found no link between radio frequency exposure and cancer.
Daniel Agresta III, the company’s president and a Brassfield parent, said students receive more RF exposure from a baby monitor than they would from the tower. Scott Hubble, an APC vice president, emphasized that improved coverage could matter during a 911 emergency at a school.
Those arguments did not disappear with Tuesday’s vote.
The summary above was compiled with the help of AI tools and edited by journalists. The full story in the link at top was reported, written and edited entirely by journalists.