undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Raleigh

Wake school board rejects cell tower at Raleigh elementary school. Here's why.

By T. Keung Hui,

3 days ago
https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=06XmlH_1HBw9Pex00
Brassfield Elementary School in in Raleigh. Wake County Public School System

A 185-foot cell phone tower will not go up on the campus of Brassfield Elementary School in Raleigh after parents and neighbors united against the project.

Parents and neighbors of Brassfield Elementary argued the tower would not fit into the North Raleigh neighborhood located in the Falls Lake watershed. In response, the Wake County school board voted 6-3 on Tuesday to reject the tower lease deal, saying they need to listen to the wishes of the school community.

“I think the tower is safe,” said board member Chris Heagarty. “But the bigger question is ultimately is it worth it to us, and is the damage to the school and the community, is that really offset by $15,000 or $30,000?”

Heagarty, Cheryl Caulfield, Lynn Edmonds, Christina Gordon, Jennifer Job and Wing Ng voted against the tower. Board vice chair Sam Hershey, Toshiba Rice and board chair Tyler Swanson voted for the lease.

APC Towers had reduced the height of the tower by 10 feet and moved it 20 feet further away from the school’s outdoor track and building. But speakers at Tuesday’s meeting said the $30,000 a year that Wake would get from the tower comes with too high a risk factor.

“It won’t make a dent in the budget deficit our district is facing,” said Ellen Gowdy, president of the PTA at Brassfield, which is opposed to the tower. “A single lawsuit related to this tower could cost the district more than it will ever bring in. This is far too much risk for little reward.”

Opposition stalled tower deal

Brassfield was slated to be the fifth Wake County school that has a cell tower on campus.

“This doesn’t mean I’m going to vote against cell towers in the future,” Job said. “If we had the funding we needed, this wouldn’t even be a discussion.”

In 2018, Wake contracted with APC-EDGE — a partnership of APC Towers and Wireless EDGE — to market, manage and develop new commercial telecommunications sites at schools. Wake said APC-EDGE is also studying towers at East Millbrook Middle in Raleigh, Fox Road Elementary in Raleigh and Hodge Road Elementary in Knightdale.

Under the Brassfield lease deal, Wake would have initially been paid $30,000 a year; the tower was to be built for Verizon to improve its cell coverage in the area. APC EDGE says Wake could have potentially earned $1.5 million over 25 years depending on how many other providers wanted to use the tower.

“I understand it’s a little amount, but it adds up,” Hershey said Tuesday.

The board tabled the lease vote on Oct. 20, sending it back to the facilities’ committee. The decision came after multiple Brassfield parents and neighbors spoke out against the lease deal.

Opponents raised concerns such as the potential health impact of radio frequency radiation from the tower, the impact on property values and the risk of debris falling from the tower on the nearby track. The tower would have been 96 feet from the track.

Board sides with parents

APC reiterated that studies don’t show that there’s a health risk from the RF radiation that would come from the tower.

Speakers at Tuesday’s board meeting argued the scientific data is far less certain than what APC is saying about the potential health risks.

“Our children should not become unwilling participants in an experiment because others are willing to accept uncertainty on their behalf,” said Brassfield parent Maxwell Darch.

Speakers said it’s up to the board to stand with them and not the tower company.

“This board has an opportunity to get this right,” said Brassfield parent Stephanie Rockwell. “ You guys can stand up for Brassfield and for our children. Listen to the families that you represent.”

That sentiment resonated with board members on Tuesday.

“Regardless of whether I feel this radio frequency is safe or not safe., I still have to understand, for my constituents, they do have concerns about it,” said Ng.

emoji_like
2

Comments