undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Chatham County

Housing developer's last-minute changes, $1.5M offer fail to sway Chatham board

By Tammy Grubb,

2 days ago
https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=1d1Ebr_1HAV2qqP00
A few hundred Chatham County residents showed up Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, for the Fearrington Preserve development hearing. About half stayed through the end of the night, clapping as four of five Chatham County commissioners rejected the project. Tammy Grubb/tgrubb@newsobserver.com

Residents opposed to hundreds of densely packed homes planned for a forest filled with creeks and wetlands in northern Chatham County won their fight Monday.

The Chatham County Board of Commissioners voted 4-1 to reject Fearrington Preserve, a 630-home development proposed for 365 acres south of Briar Chapel. An attorney for the developer warned the land will be developed anyway — up to 400 market-rate homes are allowed under the current zoning.

The applause from the crowd filled the auditorium each time a commissioner confirmed that they would vote no.

Commissioner Karen Howard, the lone vote for the project, thanked the developer for making some improvements. She also acknowledged the project’s potential to affect those in the room, but said Chatham needs more housing for a range of incomes.

There is “real merit in this plan that is worth pursuing,” Howard said.

“I think the improvement in the amount of square footage [for] commercial is significant. The commitment to Pokeberry Creek,” she said. “There’s going to be development there, and we’re going to have impacts, and so to me the bigger concern is what are we getting out of it as a county.”

What to know about Fearrington Preserve

The proposed compact community has been the subject of significant criticism among residents and county planning officials for the better part of the year. In October, the county’s Planning Board voted 8-3 to recommend the commissioners reject it.

The community envisioned by Texas-based Fearrington Property Development LLC offered five dense subdivisions split by Pokeberry Creek, a major Haw River tributary. It would have added homes and townhomes, and preserved about 183 acres.

The developer also offered a number of last-minute changes, from doubling the amount of commercial space to 36,000 square feet Monday to offering a $1.5 million payment to the county toward affordable housing and traffic needs just days before the vote.

The county would also have received 8.5 donated acres for up to 72 affordable townhomes, instead of requiring the developer to build affordable homes in the project as the county ordinance mandates.

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=04d2xx_1HAV2qqP00

Residents were especially concerned about the potential for environmental damage to a site that has at least 31 wetlands and 15 streams in addition to Pokeberry Creek.

Briar Chapel resident and aquatic biologist John Alderman previously urged a development moratorium, warning that “all our streams will soon look like Pokeberry Creek — blown up, blown out, in highly degraded urban streams.”

A U.S. Army Corps of Engineers restoration project is expected to proceed without the developer, county officials have said.

Traffic and pedestrian safety were also key concerns, since the narrow, two-lane roads around the site are already congested with parents dropping off their students at four nearby schools.

A traffic study estimated the project could add another 6,398 daily trips on a sidewalk-less stretch of Andrews Store Road — more than doubling the current daily vehicle trips. The developer offered turn lanes and two roundabouts, with the possibility for a traffic signal study in the future.

What the commissioners said about it

Howard and Commissioners Chair Amanda Robertson gave the developer’s attorney a chance to address the planning staff’s list of concerns, but the conversation quickly fell apart. Robertson said her vote would be “a hard no,” as she questioned the flooding risk, traffic and the affordable housing location, separated from the other homes by roads and creeks.

Vice Chair Franklin Gomez Flores and Commissioner Mike Roberson shared those concerns, noting potential environmental issues and the previous use of the affordable housing site as a farm’s hog lagoon.

“I wouldn’t want to live in that kind of a situation,” Gomez Flores said.

Roberson thanked the developer for making adjustments, while taking a minute to address affordable housing that is not very affordable.

“I just don’t think affordable housing is where we need to be,” he said, noting prices that range from $250,000 to $400,000.

“That’s not affordable to people making $50,000 a year. I think we need $150,000 houses … and it needs to be in Goldston and it needs to be in Siler City,” Roberson said.

Commissioner Katie Kenlan said her experience watching the project evolve was baffling, from why the developer chose to pursue a compact community zoning to why the project did not offer more details.

“You really put us in a hard place as commissioners with our community, and I feel that you took up a lot of my time to try to make sure that I do make a good decision for you … but you also didn’t take many of the recommendations of our staff,” she said.

NC Reality Check is an N&O series holding those in power accountable and shining a light on public issues that affect the Triangle or North Carolina. Have a suggestion for a future story? Email realitycheck@newsobserver.com.

Fearrington Preserve, a community of 573 homes and townhomes, was proposed for 365 acres surrounding Pokeberry Creek, south of Andrews Store Road and Briar Chapel in Chatham County.

Comments