undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Ring camera caught murder suspect returning with the gun, SC prosecutor says
By Andrew Dys,
11 days agoAfter 19-year-old Camariya Tidwell was shot and killed in May outside her family’s Rock Hill, South Carolina, home, doorbell video widely circulated online showed the suspect, Sean Xavier Hubbard, hours earlier allegedly firing a shotgun at the front door.
That shocking video was taken hours before prosecutors say Hubbard went back to the house and killed Tidwell.
Now, prosecutors say they have three more videos police used to identify Hubbard on May 16 when Tidwell was gunned down. That includes two videos of him near the house when Tidwell was killed, and at his parents’ house afterward with the murder weapon.
After Hubbard was caught shooting at the house “in broad daylight,” another video shows Hubbard “creeping into the front yard at night where he “murdered an innocent” 19-year-old girl, prosecutor Hannah Woods told visiting Judge Eugene Griffith in court Nov. 5.
“He’s then caught on video leaving the scene, he’s then caught on video at his parents’ house by their Ring camera returning with the murder weapon, wearing the same clothes he was wearing at the time of the murder.”
Hubbard denies charges
Hubbard, 35, has been in jail without bail since his arrest hours after Tidwell died. He is charged with murder, two counts of shooting into a dwelling, and two weapons charges.
He denies involvement in the case and says it is a case of mistaken identity even with the videos that police and prosecutors say put him at the scene and with the murder weapon.
He also claims that a typographical error on a police report connected to the case that used the wrong last name means that the charges against him should be thrown out. Yet his lawyer and Judge Griffith told him the error that has been fixed does not mean the charges should be dismissed.
The Herald was the only media organization present in court on Nov. 5 when he again sought to get a new lawyer and denied the charges.
“I’m still waiting on my reason to be here,” Hubbard told Griffith in court. “Someone with the wrong identity, you can’t go forward with any process.”
Hubbard claimed in a previous hearing in August covered exclusively by The Herald that he was in Albemarle, N.C. the day Tidwell was killed and wanted a new court-appointed lawyer instead of the public defender he has. A judge in August denied that request.
Hubbard told Griffith, “I really just want a fair chance to present my case,” and said he wanted to be freed from custody to do so.
He said he wanted to “best represent myself.”
“The people are ready to hear my voice,” he said in court.
Griffith, the judge, declined to give him a new lawyer and told the public defender’s office to add another attorney from the office to assist with Hubbard’s defense.
What happens next?
Near the end of the Nov. 5 hearing, Tidwell’s mother, Shifarnia McCullough, spoke out from the courtroom gallery saying: “I’m going to pray for you - you murdered my daughter” before she walked out of the courtroom.
McCullough and other family have attended previous hearings against Hubbard and vowed to keep fighting for justice for Tidwell.
Hubbard remains jailed without bail.
He faces up to life in prison if convicted of murder.
Hubbard has not been convicted of any crimes in connection to the shootings. In any criminal case and trial, the burden of proof is on prosecutors to try and prove his guilt.
A York County grand jury has indicted Hubbard, so the case is in a posture where prosecutors could schedule a trial. But it does not appear that will happen in the coming months.
Still another judge could hear Hubbard’s legal representation request before the case moves forward.