undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
NYPD updates patrol guide for the ICE age
By Joe Anuta,
2 days agoNYPD ANTI-FREEZE: The NYPD is tightening its protocols when it comes to interactions with federal immigration officials.
In a three-page revision this week to its patrol guide, officers are now required to activate their body-worn cameras whenever they encounter federal agents. They must try to obtain the identities of federal officers. And senior officers are now automatically dispatched to the scene of any encounter with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement instead of merely being called and tasked with consulting the department’s legal division.
Prohibited activities are now laid out in detail: Officers cannot tell the feds where an individual is or detain them for the purposes of immigration enforcement. They cannot close streets or allow any department properties to be used in immigration enforcement.
The patrol guide — which outlines all manner of protocol and conduct for the nation’s largest police department — also contains two new reminders: If a protest materializes against an entity like ICE, New Yorkers are entitled to their First Amendment rights. And officers are required to notify higher command if they witness or are told of misconduct allegations against federal, state or city law enforcement.
The update comes on the heels of three other additions to the patrol guide from late September, copies of which were reviewed by Playbook.
One of them prevents officers from complying with requests for a custody transfer based on civil immigration enforcement. Another lays out what officers should do if immigration officials seek to access department property that is not typically open to the public. And the third details how NYPD officials are to handle requests for information.
An NYPD spokesperson said the additions to the patrol guide largely enshrine practices the department already employs.
The NYPD, for example, has not complied with a civil immigration detainer request in the last decade. And after an anti-ICE protest in Manhattan last month, the NYPD officers on hand activated their body-worn cameras and the footage was released to the public.
“These are existing practices that the NYPD is already following,” spokesperson Brad Weekes said in a statement. “The patrol guide is merely reflecting those practices.”
Taken together, the additions to the guide point to a palpable shift in how the city deals with immigration enforcement in the age of President Donald Trump, and are part of a much broader effort to ensure agencies are complying with sanctuary city policies.
In February, Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed an executive order mandating an audit of several city agencies and how they interface with federal immigration efforts. While the resulting report released in May found city policies largely effective, the audit found several areas that could be strengthened — a realization that prompted the patrol guide update and policy shifts at multiple agencies including the NYPD.
“In a prior environment where you may have had mutual respect for each other’s policies, even if you didn’t agree — we no longer saw that,” said one person familiar with the city’s efforts who spoke with Playbook, referring to a shift in federal immigration tactics. “We saw an abusive enforcement arm, and one that didn’t regard the steps and policies we had in place.”
And so City Hall began working in collaboration with the NYPD and other agencies on putting into writing more backstops against incursions by the feds.
“Underpinning the goals behind our local laws — including the ones applied to these updated policies — are ensuring that New Yorkers maintain trust in local government,” the person who spoke with Playbook said. — Joe Anuta
FROM CITY HALL
HACK BACKLASH: Mamdani’s administration is facing pressure to reinforce New York City’s cybersecurity safeguards after revelations that hackers have stolen financial and medical data for as many as 4,000 retired municipal workers.
As first reported by POLITICO this morning, the unknown hackers recently cracked into a database that had been set up for the purpose of the city reimbursing municipal retirees for co-pays they weren’t supposed to have to pay for medical visits.
As part of the intrusion, the hackers gained access to financial and medical information on retirees who had submitted those details into the database in order to get in line for reimbursements. The hackers then apparently tried to use that information to file fraudulent claims — but EmblemHealth, the insurance company the city uses for its retiree health plan, stressed yesterday that no payouts have been issued to anyone.
Still, City Council member Virginia Maloney, who chairs the chamber’s Economic Development Committee, said the Mamdani administration must take proactive steps in light of the hack.
“The City needs to take a hard look at our cybersecurity standards, strengthen oversight of 3rd party vendors, and invest in digital infrastructure,” Maloney posted on X. “The affected retirees should be contacted immediately. Modernizing government is essential to creating secure and reliable systems.”
Maloney’s reference to third parties is notable. The retiree database the hackers accessed earlier this fall was created by Atticus Administration, a third party vendor that Emblem Health and Mamdani’s administration is relying on to process the co-pay reimbursement payouts.
Mamdani spokesperson Matthew Rauschenbach said the administration is “deeply troubled” by the Atticus hack, but did not commit to alerting impacted retirees or cracking down on Atticus. Rauschenbach did note that Atticus was contracted by Emblem, not by the city.
"Atticus must conduct a full investigation of this breach and fully cooperate with any law enforcement investigation,” Rauschenbach said.
Atticus hasn’t returned multiple requests for comment since yesterday. It’s unclear if any law enforcement agencies are looking into the hack.
The retiree database intrusion comes amid heightened concern worldwide about how artificial intelligence models are making it easier to launch cyberattacks.
Also responding to the news of the Atticus hack, Council member Chi Ossé, a democratic socialist ally of Mamdani, said “local governments must move to harden our defenses.”
“That’s why I introduced legislation requiring NYC to develop a specialized plan for AI incidents that compromise City systems and infrastructure,” he added, referring to a bill he introduced as part of a legislative package the Council is pursuing related to regulating AI. — Chris Sommerfeldt
HORSING AROUND: Mamdani signed a bill into law this morning that bans horse-drawn carriages in New York City, the culmination of a decades-long fight by animal rights activists to outlaw the tourist attraction.
But while the legislative war’s won, the court battle is just getting started.
Minutes after Mamdani put his signature on the bill, the Transport Workers Union, which advocates for the city’s roughly 200 carriage drivers, filed a federal lawsuit seeking to block the legislation, calling it “an unconstitutional abomination.”
“It strips horse-carriage owners of the city-issued medallions that they purchased for hundreds of thousands of dollars — without mandating or guaranteeing compensation,” TWU International President John Samuelsen said in a statement.
The suit, filed in Manhattan federal court, asks a judge to immediately implement a temporary restraining order putting the new law on ice.
As it relates to compensation, Mamdani said during a bill signing ceremony at City Hall that his administration will reimburse carriage owners for their medallions once the ban takes effect in 2028 — a commitment he didn’t immediately make after the legislation passed the City Council last month. But the mayor would not say how much money he will set aside for that purpose.
“I have to just focus on my letter,” he said, while in the middle of signing the bill, when Playbook asked about the budget for medallion buybacks.
“I’m not the expert that can do the analysis on what medallions cost,” Council member Christopher Marte, who penned the horse carriage ban bill, said after the ceremony when asked how much drivers should be paid. “But [Mamdani administration officials] have the people that are doing what needs to get done to make sure that these workers are taken care of.”
Animal rights advocates have called for banning the city’s horse carriage industry for decades, arguing the practice is dangerous to both animals and humans. Until now, though, mayors have failed to get legislation passed to abolish the industry, in part due to pushback from the Transport Workers Union.
Former Mayor Bill de Blasio, who showed up to today’s bill signing, promised during his first 2013 campaign for City Hall that he would ban the industry on “Day 1” of his administration. Needless to say, he never made good on that pledge.
“You know, there’s so many things in public life where you look back and say, ‘Maybe if we had tried a different strategy, it would have worked better,’ and I’m perfectly comfortable with that,” de Blasio told reporters after the ceremony. “But this day is sort of the end of what’s really been a 20-year fight, and it’s quite beautiful.” — Chris Sommerfeldt
BILL ON THE SIDELINES: In a brief interview with Playbook after the bill signing ceremony, de Blasio lauded New York Sen. Chuck Schumer as “one of the architects” behind the blue wave in this month’s midterms.
But de Blasio — who benefited from Schumer endorsements in his 2013and 2017 mayoral runs — declined to back the hometown lawmaker for another term as Senate majority leader.
“I’m not here to say what the members of the Senate want to do,” he said in the City Hall Rotunda. “But I do think one thing that’s on everyone’s mind is we just saw an absolutely seismic result, and he was one of the architects of it, so I think that that’s going to matter a lot to the senators who are voting.”
De Blasio’s hesitation comes as Schumer faces a challenge from Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen for the majority leader post.
Democrats on the party’s left flank are increasingly calling for Schumer’s ouster. Mamdani is among the notable Democrats who have declined to offer support for Schumer’s bid for another term as majority leader.
Also today, POLITICO Magazine reported on growing pressure on Schumer to retire when his current term is up at the end of 2028. If Schumer doesn’t retire, it appears likely he could face a credible primary challenge from the left.
De Blasio declined to chime in on whether Schumer should seek a sixth term in 2028. “That’s not something that any of us should comment on,” he said. “That’s his choice.” — Chris Sommerfeldt
FROM THE DELEGATION
HOME DEPO: Republican Rep.-elect Anthony Constantino will be deposed on Dec. 1 in the defamation case filed against him by Conservative Party Chair Gerard Kassar.
The lawsuit stems from Constantino claiming Kassar, a longtime political leader, threatened to kill him. The incoming House lawmaker also suggested Kassar may have tried to murder a campaign press aide.
Kassar’s suit was put on hold during Constantino’s ultimately successful campaign to succeed GOP Rep. Elise Stefanik. Now with the election over, Kassar’s legal team this week pushed for Constantino to testify. — Nick Reisman
IN OTHER NEWS
— DATA CENTERS: Debates over data centers and their water and energy consumption are roiling communities in the Hudson Valley and upstate. (The New York Times)
— HIRE AND ICE: A former New York City police officer — who was arrested and fired for driving without a license in 2023 — now works as an ICE deportation officer based in Manhattan. (New York Focus)
— BUILDING COLLAPSE: A group of construction workers injured in a Brooklyn building collapse last week are suing the developer, several construction companies, engineers and the fallen building’s owner. (Daily News)
Missed this morning’s New York Playbook? We forgive you. Read it here.