undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
New Jersey

Tesla exemption champion now seeks to repeal it

By Matt Friedman,

2 days ago

Good Wednesday morning!

When Elon Musk in 2014 complained about former Gov. Chris Christie administration’s threat to shut down Tesla on-site sales locations because they didn’t comply with the state-mandated dealership model, Assembly Majority Leader Lou Greenwald pledged to “work with my colleagues in the Legislature to clean up the governor’s mess.”

Greenwald was the top sponsor of legislation Christie signed into law less than a year later that was tailored to Tesla, allowing electric car manufacturers to have a limited number of direct-sales showrooms.

Of course, that was before Musk made his hard right turn. And now, following Senate President Nick Scutari, Greenwald, a fellow Democrat, is leading the effort in the lower house to repeal it. On Monday, he became the Assembly sponsor of Scutari’s bill.

Greenwald in a phone interview told me it’s not about Musk but rather about Tesla going back on its promises during negotiations over the 2015 law. Back then, Teslas were almost a novelty in New Jersey. Now, they’re common.

“When we created this [law], we did so because I was and remain wildly impressed by the product. It was a new product that needed introduction into the marketplace,” said Greenwald, who sold cars when he was a college student and remains a passionate advocate of the franchise system. “It was innovative, it was new, it was unproven, and the public needed an opportunity to have access to it.”

Greenwald claimed Tesla abandoned its promises — including, he said, that the company would adopt the franchise model once its market share had grown — while it used “loopholes” to expand its showrooms beyond what the law explicitly permitted. Greenwald also faulted Tesla for downgrading its customer service.

“My argument is: Congratulations, you’ve made it. You should follow the same laws as everybody else and be responsive to the consumers,” said Greenwald.

It’s sometimes hard to measure a bill's chance of passage. Legislation is often introduced to send a message or please a constituency or group. In this case, the New Jersey Coalition of Automotive Retailers has been pushing for it. It probably does speak to the bill’s chances that it has the backing of the top state senator and now the second highest-ranking assemblymember.

Greenwald said he believes the legislation has a good chance at passing. But this may not be as easy a political lift as it seems. As much as many people, progressive or otherwise, dislike Musk, there’s many who have had bad car dealership experiences. And based on the feedback I’ve gotten to this legislation before, many of them are willing to concede Musk is right on at least this point.

I take Greenwald at his word that this isn’t about Musk. He and the dealership lobby are right about the increased adoption of Teslas and other electric cars since this law was signed. But Musk’s deep unpopularity presents an obvious opportunity for anyone seeking to repeal it.

FEEDBACK? Reach me at mfriedman@politico.com

WHERE’S SHERRILL? In Atlantic City at 2 p.m. for the 2nd Annual New Jersey Statewide Black Agenda convening.

QUOTE OF THE DAY: “Hakeem deserves it to be by acclamation. That said, if winning in places we’ve never won before and having a historic majority isn’t good enough for a few of our members, then let them vote ‘no.’” — Democratic Rep. Josh Gottheimer on House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries for speaker

HAPPY BIRTHDAY: Nick Scutari

WHAT TRENTON MADE

DELAY-NEY HALL — New Jersey sues DHS for ‘stonewalling’ investigation at Delaney Hall detention center, by POLITICO’s Joey Fox and Daniel Han: New Jersey has sued the U.S. Department of Homeland Security for “stonewalling” a state investigation into the Delaney Hall immigrant detention center, state Attorney General Jennifer Davenport announced on Tuesday. The lawsuit, filed in federal court in Washington D.C., alleges that federal immigration officials have deliberately obstructed state and local oversight of the Newark facility, which is run by a private detention company, GEO Group. New Jersey announced its investigation and issued subpoenas on Aug. 7, but a demand for GEO Group records on detainee medical treatment was rejected at the direction of DHS, according to the lawsuit. “There are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of the people held at Delaney Hall,” Davenport said in a statement. “But what we have received for months from both GEO Group and DHS is plain stonewalling.”

HURD ENOUGH — “Judge dismisses malicious prosecution lawsuit against Platkin by Norcross co-defendant,” by the New Jersey Globe’s David Wildstein: “A Superior Court judge today dismissed a malicious prosecution lawsuit against former Attorney General Matt Platkin and others brought by a South Jersey real estate executive who was a co-defendant in the collapsed racketeering case against Democratic powerbroker George E. Norcross III. Mercer County Superior Court Judge Douglas H. Hurd granted a motion to dismiss the lawsuit filed by John J. O’Donnell, the former CEO of The Michaels Organization, against Platkin, Assistant Attorney General Michael Breslin, and three investigators for the now-defunct Office of Public Integrity and Accountability. The dismissal was without prejudice, giving O’Donnell until January 5, 2027, to seek permission to amend his complaint. Hurd issued his ruling after oral argument, with his reasoning on the record. The written order does not specify the grounds for dismissal. … In seeking dismissal of O’Donnell’s civil lawsuit, attorneys for Platkin and Breslin argued that prosecutors were protected by absolute and qualified immunity for actions taken in pursuing criminal charges. They also maintained that O’Donnell had failed to establish essential elements of malicious prosecution, including a lack of probable cause and evidence of malice.”

— “Philly Inquirer says Norcross' $100M suit is too late”

REGULATORS! STAND DOWN — “Assembly panel approves changes to NJ rulemaking process,” by the New Jersey Monitor’s Nikita Biryukov: “An Assembly panel on Monday approved legislation that would extend timelines for state agencies to adopt regulations, require the automatic award of attorney fees to groups or individuals who successfully challenge some rules, and expand public hearing requirements in the rulemaking process. Business groups hailed the bill, arguing it would lend new transparency to the state’s rulemaking process, but progressive and environmental groups opposed it, warning that, despite support for some transparency provisions, the bill would expand the power and influence of special interest groups stung by two recent major regulatory defeats.”

THE LEAGUE OF EXTRAORDINARILY INTOXICATED GENTLEMEN — “Everything a town could need is at the League of Municipalities conference in Atlantic City,” by The Press of Atlantic City’s Haram Shahid: “There might be a bird stuck somewhere in Mike Desorbo's Christmas tree. ‘It's a real bird. He's just joining me today,’ said Desorbo, a salesman for Holiday Outdoor Decor of Syracuse, New York. He isn't sure how it got inside the towering display tree. ‘He's been flying around. He's in there. If you hang out, he'll fly out.’ The tree peeked into every corner of the exhibition hall at the New Jersey State League of Municipalities’ annual conference, a networking event and trade show for municipal officials from across the state that runs through Thursday at the Atlantic City Convention Center. The three-day conference generates more than 8,400 hotel room rentals and $10 million in spending, according to 2021 numbers from Visit Atlantic City, an organization tasked with marketing the resort.”

— Snowflack: “On the ground in Atlantic City with LG Emehelu and the gang”

— “Man admits sending letter that threatened to kill [Bhalla’s] family, ‘feed them to the pigs’”

— “Quintero makes state Assembly bid alongside Brennan official in LD-32”

— “Sources: Two Baraka World names in the LD-28 assembly game”

— "Drivers will pay higher tolls on Parkway, NJ Turnpike for the 6th year in a row. Here’s what they’re paying for”

— “After 9-day-old died, NJ family works to improve emergency infant care”

— “Critics condemn police purchases of cars, K-9s, gym gear from NJ opioid funds”

— “More than $150 million in Stay NJ rebate checks headed to seniors”

TRUMP ERA

NEWTON GREENWICH — “The next Congress: NJ Democrats’ hopes and dreams,” by the NJ Spotlight News’ Benjamin J. Hulac: “Fresh off a Democratic sweep of both chambers of Congress, Rep. Analilia Mejia (D-11th) is channeling Newt Gingrich, the GOP politician who led the so-called 'Republican Revolution' in the 1994 midterm elections. 'History doesn’t have to repeat, but it sure does inform, Mejia said in an interview. Meanwhile, Rep. LaMonica McIver, the Democratic congresswoman from Newark, said she is setting her sights on pursuing economic bills on 'things that my residents can touch and feel.' And first-term member Rebecca Bennett is still picking committees and learning the halls of Congress — literally. … In preparation for the 120th Congress, Democrats in the New Jersey delegation are dreaming big of being in the majority in the House and Senate, none more than the relative newcomers coming off their wins in the midterms.”

POP! GO THE MEASLES — “NJ measles vaccinations drop as US loses measles-free designation,” by The Record’s Scott Fallon: “New Jersey's vaccination rates for measles, mumps and rubella now sits at its lowest point in at least a decade as the U.S. lost its measles-free status on Tuesday, Nov. 17 due to the continuous spread of the virus. The percentage of Garden State kindergarteners who received the MMR vaccine hit a low of 92.5% in the 2025-26 school year, a steady decline from a high of 96.5% in the 2016-17 school year, the latest federal data shows.”

— “Bennett, Hamawy score big in congressional office lottery; Mullock draws near bottom”

— “After more than three decades in Princeton, family with severely disabled daughter faces deportation threat”

— “New HUD rule could worsen New Jersey housing pressures”

LOCAL

IT’S LLANONELY AT THE TOP — “Camden mayor, city officials are demanding ouster of Schools Superintendent Alfonso Llano,” by The Philadelphia Inquirer’s Melanie Burney: “Camden Mayor Victor Carstarphen and the city’s top elected officials are calling on Gov. Mikie Sherrill to remove the city’s state-appointed school superintendent. In a letter dated Nov. 10 to Sherrill and state Education Commissioner Lily Laux, they cite a ‘serious concern’ made by schools chief Alfonso Q. Llano Jr. that ‘have eroded our confidence’ in his ability to lead the troubled district. The letter, obtained by The Inquirer, lists a series of grievances against Llano since he was appointed by the state in January. Among the complaints, Llano recently notified One Camden Inc., a citywide public school enrollment system, that it plans to withdraw district schools, according to the letter.”

EXILE ON STATE STREET — “Paterson police chief, replaced amid AG takeover, in Trenton until May,” by the Paterson Press’ Joe Malinconico: “The city’s police chief, Engelbert Ribeiro, faces another six months of driving to Trenton to report for work at the state’s Police Training Commission. Ribeiro’s banishment from his office at headquarters in Paterson was part of the fallout from the Attorney General’s takeover of the city police department in 2023. State officials recently decided to extend the chief’s 'temporary mobility assignment' at the training commission until May 15, 2027. Ribeiro has been making the commute to Trenton for the past three-and-a-half years, while Paterson taxpayers continue to pay his $225,000 salary.”

TOMS DRIVER — “What Toms River taxpayers pay for mayor's car gas, repairs,” by the Asbury Park Press’ Jean Mikle: “Township taxpayers have paid at least $8,658 in repairs and gasoline costs for the two vehicles Mayor Daniel Rodrick has used to commute to his personal job since he became mayor in January 2024. But whether that is all they have spent remains uncertain. The mayor has driven a municipally owned 2020 Ford Explorer and a 2024 Chevrolet Silverado since he took office. And some records show he has used $1,976 in township gasoline to fuel the vehicles through the end of August 2026. It is unclear if that represents the total of gasoline costs that the township has paid for the nearly three years since Rodrick assumed office, or if there are reimbursement expenses the mayor has filed to recoup out-of-pocket expenses related to the vehicles. … The mayor's use of the vehicles to drive to his job as vice principal of Irvington High School has angered the anti-Rodrick majority on the Township Council, who say the mayor is violating township code by continuing to drive a municipal car to his out-of-county job.”

— “Toms River: Prosecutor should butt out of police department”

GOVERNMENT WEALTHFARE — “How Trump uses 'make-believe' farming to save on Colts Neck NJ property taxes,” by the Asbury Park Press’ Mike Davis: “President Donald Trump’s eponymous golf course in this bucolic town saves tens of thousands of dollars in property taxes by claiming a popular loophole exploited by some of New Jersey’s most rich and famous residents and powerful businesses. Trump National Golf Club Colts Neck paid just $389 in property taxes for 87 acres of its sprawling golf course last year, according to municipal tax records. The club’s tax bill is vastly reduced by its qualification under the state’s Farmland Assessment program, which allows landowners who meet certain conditions to claim some or all of their property as a working farm. Trump National previously claimed 40 acres under the Farmland Assessment from 2012 to 2022, paying about $615 per year and $4,927 total. But beginning in 2023, the club increased its qualified farmland to 87 acres – paying a total of just $997 on that specific parcel since then.”

R.I.P. — “Newark leader Gayle Chaneyfield Jenkins has died,” by InsiderNJ’s Max Pizarro: “Former Newark Councilwoman, lifelong Brick City advocate, and persistent fighter leader Gayle Chaneyfield Jenkins has died after a courageous battle with pancreatic cancer. Her family issued this statement this morning on her Facebook page: It is with heavy hearts and deep sorrow that we announce the passing of Gayle Chaneyfield Jenkins. Gayle dedicated her life to serving her community and spreading love and compassion for others wherever she went. … During the James years, she served on the council from 1995 to 2006 and made a comeback in 2014, first as a Baraka ally and then as a critic of the sitting mayor.”

BACKLASH FOR ALLOWING A WAWA TO OPEN IN RAMSEY, HALF A MILE FROM ITS RIGHTFUL PLACE IN MAHWAH  — “With 22-vote lead, La Manna claims victory in Ramsey mayor race,” by The Record’s Marsha A. Stoltz: “What began as a two-vote margin has widened to 22, prompting Democratic challenger Angelo La Manna to declare victory over three-term Mayor Deidre Dillon in a race that remains days away from official certification. ’I am humbled and honored that the residents of Ramsey have selected me as their next mayor,’ La Manna said in a Nov. 17 email statement. … If certified, La Manna and his council running mates Jennifer Crandall and Robert Barry would alter the borough's all-Republican municipal government.”

— “Jersey City fire official ‘temporarily reassigned’ as alleged malfeasance probed”

— “Wanaque drops school reorganization, but budget woes remains. See why”

— "Widow sues over inmate's violent death at Burlington County Jail”

— “Cape May proposes beach tent restrictions”

— “Middle schooler sets off pepper spray in [Trenton] cafeteria, sending 20 students to the nurse”

— “Ocean County woman may avoid prison after child sex abuse images plea”

— “Cape May County seeks regional approach to affordable housing mandates”

EVERYTHING ELSE

ATLAS DRUBBED — “Their loved ones were left to rot. 11 grieving families accuse NJ nursing home operator of deadly neglect,” by NJ.com’s Jackie Roman: “The suit states Atlas Healthcare Group, the owners of the Wynwood Rehabilitation center, 'accepted Maxine Hardy as a resident, fully aware of her medical history and understood the level of nursing care required to prevent the occurrence of injuries.' But the family accuses the facility of failing her. And not just her, but at least 10 other patients of Atlas Healthcare Group. Hardy’s case is one of at least 11 lawsuits filed in New Jersey since January which allege that vulnerable residents at facilities operated by Atlas Healthcare Group suffered preventable injuries, and in many cases avoidable deaths, because of inadequate staffing and insufficient monitoring. All of the patients involved in the lawsuits, except one, died.”

— “Another new record for internet gambling revenue in New Jersey in October at $287.4M”

— “Little Steven TeachRock taking on antisemitism with Holocaust lesson”

Comments