undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Oneida County

The upstate county that bucked the blue wave

By Bill Mahoney,

6 days ago
https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=2osDWv_1H1sz5KS00

ONEIDA OUTLIER: When in Rome, vote Republican if you want to do as the locals do.

As the blue tsunami crashed over the country last week, a comprehensive list of silver linings for New York Republicans could fit on a post-it note. But it was a great night for the party in Oneida County.

Assembly candidate Mike Gentile flipped the seat that covers the cities of Utica and Rome and has remained stubbornly blue for decades. The Assembly seat was the only GOP pickup in the state Legislature’s 213 districts on a night when Democrats managed to flip 23% of the 69 seats that Republicans had won in 2024.

Meanwhile, Republican Jared Pearl ousted the county’s Democratic Sheriff Robert Maciol. A four-term incumbent, Maciol won his 2022 race with 79% of the vote.

And the county was responsible for electing Republican Anthony Constantino to Congress.

Democrat Blake Gendebien flipped the rest of that district. While Republican Elise Stefanik won the district’s 14 non-Oneida counties by 69,000 votes two years ago, Gendebien won them by 1,500. But Constantino won Oneida by 6,800 last week.

The GOP congressional campaign focused on driving up turnout in the candidate’s home turf, a corner of the district they thought Gendebien was neglecting.

Constantino consultant Alex DeGrasse said the campaign went “all in” on the Mohawk Valley “to stop the bleeding elsewhere.” Vice President JD Vance notably stopped in Rome on the eve of the election to gin up support.

Beyond motivating the base — which plenty of Republicans attempted with less success last week — area officials don’t have a silver bullet to offer their counterparts elsewhere.

Republican state Sen. Joe Griffo received 67% of the vote while winning an 11th term representing the Oneida area. He acknowledged that national politics can influence local elections in such a way that “people just get frustrated and upset and angry and say ‘I’m just going to go the other way.’”

“I always hope that people would look at the individuals regardless of the political affiliation,” Griffo said.

Of course, hundreds of down-ballot Republicans across the country hoped in vain their voters would ignore party labels. But Republicans in Griffo’s neck of the woods think the party was successful because of a more direct approach to campaigning. County GOP Chair Ellen Rayhill said before the election that she thought Gentile might flip the Assembly seat because of his focus on tactics like door-to-door outreach.

“It’s having strong candidates,” Gentile said. “It was just a consistent messaging about our community service, our public service, that resonated.”

The messaging wasn’t exclusively about the candidates.

Benji Federman, who managed Pearl’s sheriff campaign, said polling made clear that Gov. Kathy Hochul “was tremendously underwater” in the county.

“We were successfully able to leverage her unpopularity in the county and tie the incumbent to her,” he said. “Repetition and consistency — continuing to rail on bail reform, Raise the Age, discovery reform. That still connected with voters in Oneida County.”

An ad Pearl ran in the weeks before the election featured the incumbent’s face next to the menacing visages of Hochul, former Gov. Andrew Cuomo and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. “Dangerous policies from Albany have made us left safe,” the narrator said.

The Oneida sheriff’s race was far from the only contest in the state where Republicans ran on attacking Hochul — a strategy that fell flat for Bruce Blakeman, the GOP gubernatorial candidate.

But Oneida now stands alone. Other major population centers along the Erie Canal like Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse have swung hard to the left in the Trump Era. Oneida is now redder than ever.

David Catalfamo, a GOP consultant, said some of the credit for that belongs to having long-tenured Republican officials, like Griffo and County Executive Anthony Picente, helping to strengthen the party’s brand locally. But despite working in Oneida for years, he didn’t have a simple explanation as to why it avoided the wave.

“It’s a bit of an outlier,” he said. “There’s something about the demographic makeup of the county that is built into the DNA of these races.” — Bill Mahoney

FROM CITY HALL

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=3Inp3p_1H1sz5KS00

COPS CLAP BACK AT ZO: The head of the NYPD’s largest union is taking aim at Mamdani’s plan to disband the police department’s Strategic Response Group, warning it will put both “officers and the public at greater risk.”

The SRG is tasked with counterterrorism duties and responding to volatile protests. Police reform advocates and leftist politicians like Mamdani have long argued the unit must be nixed, pointing to disproportionately high rates of misconduct claims against its members.

As POLITICO first reported this morning, Mamdani’s plan to break up the unit — which could be announced as early as this week — is expected to involve creating a new civilian unit that would take the lead on responding to protests. That unit, which may be housed under Mamdani’s signature Office of Community Safety, would receive support from NYPD officers who could step in to conduct arrests during especially chaotic protests, according to a person with knowledge of the forthcoming announcement who was granted anonymity to discuss it.

Patrick Hendry, president of the Police Benevolent Association, told Playbook this afternoon the plan is dangerous and a fig leaf for Mamdani not wanting “the NYPD involved in policing demonstrations at all.”

“Forcing cops to sit on the sidelines until a demonstration has already turned violent puts both police officers and the public at greater risk,” said Hendry, whose dues-paying members include officers assigned to the SRG. “No matter what changes he makes, the mayor can't be foolish enough to believe they will satisfy his base. 'Disband SRG' was always code for 'Disband the whole NYPD,' and they won't stop until they achieve that goal."

A spokesperson for NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch, who has defended using the SRG in the past, did not immediately return a request for comment.

Mamdani made disbanding the unit a core public safety promise on the campaign trail last year. But he’s dragged his feet on making good on the vow since taking office, causing consternation within his democratic socialist base.

Word of Mamdani’s imminent SRG announcement comes just ahead of the Democratic Socialists of America’s New York City convention this Saturday. — Chris Sommerfeldt

BREAKING THE RULES: Mamdani’s administration was intimately involved in drafting a new consumer protection bill introduced today by City Council member Chi Ossé — the latest indication the mayor plans to get more directly involved in the chamber’s legislative affairs.

The bill carried by Ossé would remove a provision in local law requiring the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection to engage in 90 days of rulemaking before the agency can take enforcement action against a private business engaged in “unconscionable” trade practices. Examples of such practices include companies that provide unclear subscription cancellation policies and price-gouge on essential items during a state of emergency.

A Mamdani spokesperson confirmed to Playbook this afternoon that the mayor’s team was “very involved” in advancing Ossé’s legislation, with Department of Consumer and Worker Protection Commissioner Sam Levine helping draft the bill language.

“When working New Yorkers lose money to subscription traps and other deceptive corporate schemes, the City shouldn’t have to wait on a lengthy bureaucratic process just to fight back,” Mamdani said in a statement, adding that Ossé’s bill will allow the DCWP “to take action the minute they see a corporation taking advantage of New Yorkers.”

The Ossé bill, the Unconscionable Consumer Abuse Prevention Act, appears to be just the second piece of Council legislation Mamdani has gotten directly involved in from the jump since becoming mayor. Last month, he helped Council member Harvey Epstein introduce legislation that would give private individuals the right to file civil lawsuits against companies over unfair and abusive business practices.

A spokesperson for Council Speaker Julie Menin, who is a former DCWP commissioner, declined to immediately comment on the substance of Ossé’s bill, only saying she looks forward to “seeing this go through the legislative process.”

Ossé expressed optimism his bill will move quickly through the chamber, with 12 of his colleagues already signed on as co-sponsors.

“The days of New Yorkers being taken advantage of by businesses that bet you’re too busy, confused, or overwhelmed to fight back are ending,” he said. — Chris Sommerfeldt

BUDGET BOOST: The Mamdani administration released the city’s annual mid-fiscal-year checkup on its finances today. And the tidy revenue uptick laid out in that November Financial Plan will help the mayor balance next year’s budget.

In the months since the city’s adopted budget was passed on June 30, the city has collected $965 million more in tax revenue than it had anticipated, a boost driven by soaring Wall Street profits. City Hall beancounters have also booked around $683 million more in savings across this fiscal year and next.

“New Yorkers deserve a government that works as hard as they do, and that is as careful with their money as they are,” Mamdani said in a statement. “Our budget proves that fiscal responsibility and public excellence go hand in hand.”

The modest windfall, however, is nowhere near enough to solve the more systemic fiscal risks that await the mayor. Next year’s budget gap still stands north of $6 billion and is projected to grow closer to $9 billion in the two years following.

“The City has much more work to do to achieve meaningful savings and put its finances on a sustainable path,” City Comptroller Mark Levine said in a statement. — Joe Anuta

IN OTHER NEWS

— VIOLATING: Mark Schwartz, a landlord who’s been celebrated by Mamdani, has racked up hundreds of housing code violations. (The City Reporter)

— SHELTER SHAME: Plans to build a men’s shelter one block from a Brooklyn middle school has sparked outrage from parents, teachers and Council Member Mercedes Narcisse. (New York Post)

— GREEN WAVE: Climate-minded progressives who ran on anger over energy bills are heading to Albany next year, which could put the state’s climate movement back on the offensive. (New York Focus)

Missed this morning’s New York Playbook? We forgive you. Read it here.

emoji_like
emoji_angry
emoji_love
50

Comments / 15