undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Defendants in housing development suit ask that it be dismissed
By JIM PHILLIPS,
2026-02-11The defendants in a lawsuit filed by a group of property owners in a Thornville housing development, who are seeking information that includes a full accounting of the community’s financial records, have asked a judge to dismiss the suit.
As previously reported in The Perry County Tribune, in October 2025 a group of 19 residents of the Snug Harbor Estates Community filed a civil complaint in Perry County Common Pleas Court, naming as defendants the Snug Harbor Master Association, the Snug Harbor Estates Community Association, and Triglyph Holdings LLC. The suit says that Triglyph developed the Snug Harbor Estates Community by selling real property to individuals including the plaintiffs, and created the Master Association and Community Association in April 2012.
The plaintiffs have claimed that their attorney has sent a letter to “some or all” of the defendants, asking for a list of items that includes the articles of incorporation and code of regulations for the community; names and addresses of all current members of the Community Association’s board of trustees; the name of the president and/or owner of Triglyph Holdings; minutes from board meetings from 2022 to the present; any and all contracts with any entity or individual that provided any services or benefits to the community for which dues and/or assessments were paid; names of all lot owners in the Community Association; and a chance to inspect the community’s financial records.
However, the suit alleges, the defendants have “only provided some of the requested information.”
Because the defendants have not fulfilled their legal obligations to the plaintiffs, the complaint argues, the plaintiffs should be allowed to stop paying their Community Association fees until the requested records have been provided to them.
On Jan. 9, the Snug Harbor Master Association and the Snug Harbor Estates Community Association filed a joint response to the lawsuit, followed a week later by a response from Triglyph Holdings. The two responses, which largely overlap in their content,
Both deny the key allegations in the lawsuit, and allege that before the suit was filed, a number of the defendants were delinquent in paying their assessments to the Community Association, in amounts ranging from a little over $1,100 to more than $6,000.
The responses also state that before the complaint was filed, the Community Association had emailed “most of the requested documents and information” to the plaintiffs who are property owners, and also to other property owners. They deny, however, the lawsuit’s allegation that, based on the declarations governing the community, the plaintiffs “are entitled to a full and complete accounting regarding the financial records of the Community, including but not limited to examining QuickBooks, bank records, P&L statements, and contracts with third-party vendors.”
The plaintiffs have asked for a declaration from the court that says they are not required to pay their Community Association fees because of the defendants’ failure to meet their legal obligations, or in the alternative, that the plaintiffs can pay their fees into an escrow account while the dispute is sorted out.
In their responses, the defendants “deny that Plaintiffs are entitled to any such declaration.”
As previously reported in The Perry County Tribune, in a lawsuit filed in 2022, investors who claimed they had loaned over $2.2 million to Snug Harbor’s developers and gotten almost no return asked the Franklin County Common Pleas Court to put eight companies involved with the housing development into receivership.
The plaintiffs in that case, like those in the new litigation, alleged that they had been denied access to financial records relating to the project. That lawsuit is still pending, according to online court records, of Franklin County Common Pleas Court, and on Feb. 4 of this year, the plaintiffs filed a motion asking the court to order the defendants to show cause why they should not be held in contempt of court for alleged “repeated violations” of court orders related to the case.
Snug Harbor, which reportedly ran into major financial difficulties within about a year of its being launched in 2009, has generated multiple lawsuits including many in Perry County Common Pleas Court.
Email at jphillips@perrytribune.com