undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Owatonna

Aderman Hall pool currently needs $475,000 in repairs

By KAITA GORSUCH,

13 days ago

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=2MX6hu_1Gr6hJGE00

The 112-year-old Aderman Hall pool at West Hills is in need of some updating.

About 5,500 or more people use the West Hills pool annually for swimming lessons, water aerobics, family open swim and rentals, along with trainings for lifeguards and water safety instructors.

“There’s really no practical indoor replacement in Owatonna for a pool,” Facilities and Fleet Director Patrick McDermott told the city council during its Wednesday study session. “The only other option — especially in the wintertime — would be the Owatonna Middle School, and that really does not have good access.”

When the West Hills pool had to close in the spring for repairs, the local hotels with pools were contacted about availability for swimming lessons.

“We got three responses with limited or no availability, and the remaining six did not respond,” McDermott said. “I think they just didn’t want the liability of making that a public pool within a hotel would be our assumption on that.”

Large pool repairs history

After its construction in 1914, the West Hills pool went about 84 years without record of major repairs. In 1998, a fiberglass pool liner was installed. In 2003, and ADA-compliant restroom and lift were installed thanks to an Owatonna Foundation grant. A new main drain was installed in 2010, and 16 years later a new compliant main drain was installed with a 10-year expiration.

Between 1998 and 2015, the pool transitioned from gas chlorine to liquid chlorine and had sand filters, multiple new circulation pumps and a new pool heater — a transition from the full facility boiler system — installed. These repairs were listed with no known installation date.

In 2026, the city has installed a compliant main drain cover, patched and repaired short-term pool shell leaks and replaced the lighting to LEDs — all in July. Currently in the work plan is repairing the ADA restroom ceiling grid and replacing the heater.

These “larger” pool repairs do not include basic daily repairs, maintenance or painting, McDermott said.

Current, long-term needs

While the presentation at the council study session was just informative, McDermott said the pool’s current needs are the HVAC system, — which would cost about $27,600 and is subject to load calculation review — the pool’s 28-year-old liner — which could cost $35,000 or more to replace the fiberglass, or $92,000 to replaster — and the circulation plumbing — which would cost about $196,000.

“I don’t think you can pick one without the other,” McDermott said. “Could you hold off on painting walls or resurfacing the floor or tile? Yeah, if if there wasn’t enough money to do all those, those would probably be part two. But part one would need to be the liner, the plumbing and the HVAC system.”

Future needs include the ADA chair lift, structural engineering analysis of the subterranean walls, main drain replacement every 10 years, pool heater lifecycle replacement and repairing the pool filtration system.

“I think most of the other mechanical in that building is in pretty good shape. There’ll be a point where it’ll have to be replaced, but everything else has been replaced over time, and it’s in reasonable shape,” McDermott said. “There’s been preventive maintenance on that pool over the years, but we’re just to the end of the useful life on the liner. We don’t have money in the capital plan right now to to replace that this year or next. It’s not currently in the budget, so if we have to limp it along with some patches and things, we’ll continue to do that until council decides where they would like that to fit in the priorities list.”

The total for the three most pressing pool needs is about $258,600 on the low end and $315,600 on the high end, not including professional fees or any changes identified with the State Historic Preservation Office. Including “part two” of the pool’s needs would bring the cost to $475,000

Next steps

McDermott had also researched the needs for the rest of Aderman Hall, and he estimated that the building’s current needs total to $510,000 or more in repairs, while anticipating it will need $350,000 or more in repairs in the future.

“Ultimately, the council needs to decide what they would like to do,” McDermott said. “Do we want to keep an operating swimming pool long term?”

The prices he presented to the council on Wednesday were “rough costs,” so McDermott said if council approved moving forward with repairs the numbers would need refined. He also recommended a structural engineering evaluation and HVAC mechanical analysis, which wouldn’t be “overly expensive.”

“I wouldn’t want to go make a big investment in relining the pool and doing those things if we have some structural issues we need to take care of,” he said. “We’ve patched it and and put some short term fixes in, and the pool is operable, but is there some risk that we could continue to have some issues just because of the age of the liner?”

Council discussion

Council President Kevin Raney asked if the city was to spend over $500,000 on repairing a 100-year-old building, wouldn’t it be easier to use that money to “put a building up around” the water park on the north end of town.

“I know it’s going to cost more than $500,000, but would that be an option to look at?” he asked.

Councilor Don McCann agreed, saying if the city was going to “do the forensic” on the existing facility, it would be fair to do a “cursory analysis” on what it would cost to build a new facility over the water park.

“Some of us talk about ‘Take care of our own buildings.’ It all goes hand-in-hand with taxes,” Councilor Dan Boeke said. “Do we want to spend more in taxes to take care of our own buildings? Have we already said enough is enough for this 114-year-old, oldest operating pool in Minnesota?”

Boeke also said the “elephant in the room” was the two biggest structures the city needed to take care of first.

“Before we put a nickel in this place, we got to figure out what to do with police and fire,” he said. “Right now we’re talking about $510,000, where’s the money gonna come from? We hear plenty of ‘Don’t raise the taxes, live within your means.’ Does live within your means mean fixing this 104-year-old building? I can’t justify doing anything with that before we take care of police and fire.”

Comments