undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen in Ohio Serves Thanksgiving Every Day
By Jacki Mick,
4 hours agoThanksgiving is a lovely holiday in theory. In practice, it involves three days of cooking, a kitchen full of relatives asking whether they can help (they cannot), and enough dirty dishes to qualify as a municipal emergency. Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen in Middlefield, Ohio, offers a considerably more appealing arrangement: roast turkey, savory dressing, mashed potatoes, gravy, and homemade pie, without anyone having to baste a bird or explain to Uncle Gary why the stuffing is taking so long. And the best part? You don’t have to wait until the fourth Thursday in November to enjoy it.
Located in the heart of Northeast Ohio’s Amish Country, Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen has been feeding hungry travelers since 1987. Owned by Dan and Rita Miller, the business includes a full-service restaurant, bakery, gift shop, and private banquet room. Middlefield is the center of the world’s fourth-largest Amish community, making it a particularly good place to arrive hungry and leave with far more baked goods than you planned.
Why Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen Is One of the Best Year-Round Holiday Restaurants in Ohio
There are plenty of comfort food restaurants Ohians swear by, but Mary Yoder’s has something that makes it especially appealing: breakfast, lunch, dinner, and a buffet that understands the emotional importance of mashed potatoes.
The restaurant serves an all-you-can-eat buffet and salad bar Monday through Saturday. The buffet selection changes, but familiar Amish favorites include broasted or baked chicken, dressing, mashed potatoes, noodles, vegetables, homemade macaroni and cheese, and other hearty dishes. The salad bar has fresh greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, beets, peas, hard-boiled eggs, cottage cheese, and assorted prepared salads.
It is the sort of place where one person carefully assembles a respectable plate, and another makes three trips before dessert. Neither approach is wrong. The dinner buffet is listed at $19.99, with salad-bar-only dining at $13.99. Breakfast buffet pricing is listed at $12.99. Confirm current prices before heading out, because no one wants a buffet surprise that isn’t a dessert they weren’t expecting.
The Turkey Dish That Locals Enjoy All Year Long
The roast turkey dinner is a particularly good choice for anyone craving Thanksgiving without the accompanying family negotiations. In addition to making appearances on the buffet line, the regular menu also includes hot roast turkey and roast beef sandwiches, along with grilled ham with pineapple, another dish that feels perfectly comfortable at a holiday table.
The dressing and Amish mashed potatoes are natural companions. Add gravy and a vegetable, and suddenly the calendar becomes largely irrelevant. The buffet also offers Amish wedding noodles, which can be served over mashed potatoes for a traditional Amish combination. Carbohydrate enthusiasts, consider this your championship game.
The menu goes well beyond turkey, with homemade meatloaf, cod fillet, fried chicken, hot trail bologna and Middlefield Swiss sandwiches, burgers, and Yoder’s ground steak sandwich. Small-town restaurants worth the drive should give visitors something distinctive to eat, and that trail bologna sandwich certainly qualifies.
What Else To Order at Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen
Save room for the bakery. Actually, make a plan for the bakery. There is a difference.
Mary Yoder’s makes extra-deep 10-inch pies in an impressive assortment of varieties, including apple, Dutch apple, blueberry, bumbleberry, cherry, cherry crumb, elderberry, peach, pecan, pumpkin, strawberry rhubarb, and rhubarb crumb. Cream pies include banana, butterscotch, chocolate, coconut, lemon, peanut butter, raspberry, and chocolate peanut butter. Sugar-free apple, blueberry, cherry, and pumpkin pies are available, too. Whole pies require 24 hours’ notice, so call ahead rather than arriving with the confidence of someone who thinks an entire peach pie materializes on demand.
The cookie selection is equally formidable. Chocolate chip, maple, molasses, monster, oatmeal butterscotch, oatmeal raisin, peanut butter, raisin-filled cookies, raisin puffs, snickerdoodles, and sugar cookies are among the choices. Bar cookies include brownies, lemon bars, pumpkin bars, M&M Dream Bars, and Can’t Leave Alone Bars.
Christmas brings seasonal treats such as chocolate peppermint crinkles, raspberry shortbreads, peanut butter blossoms, Russian tea cakes, and drizzled molasses cookies. Fresh breads and dinner rolls make excellent additions to the haul, adding Mary Yoder’s Amish Buffet firmly to the list of Ohio buffets worth the trip. The bakery also offers online ordering and shipping.
What Else There Is To Do At This Ohio Turkey Restaurant
The gift shop is worth browsing after lunch, particularly for handmade items and locally inspired gifts. The bakery selection provides another excellent reason to linger. Mary Yoder’s also accommodates Amish visitors with a hitching area for horse-drawn buggies behind the parking lot. Keep an eye out for buggies on the surrounding roads and give them plenty of room.
For another stop, head to Rothenbuhler Cheese Chalet in Middlefield for locally made cheese. The surrounding countryside, with its farms, Amish homes, and winding roads, makes the drive part of the experience, especially when the autumn leaves begin showing off.
What To Know Before You Go
Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen is located at 14743 North State Street in Middlefield, Ohio. The restaurant is open Monday through Saturday from 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. and closed Sundays. Breakfast runs from 6 to 11 a.m., while the dinner buffet is available from 11:30 a.m. until closing. Call (440) 632-1939 to confirm current hours, prices, and daily buffet selections.
The restaurant offers carryout, family-style meals for groups of at least 15, and an online store for bakery items and gifts. You can buy leftover buffet food for takeout at $7.99 per pound, rather than packing it into a traditional buffet to-go container.
Mary Yoder’s belongs on the itinerary for anyone exploring Ohio’s Amish Country, particularly those who appreciate the sort of classic American comfort food that has kept iconic diners across the country in business for generations. Spend some time in Middlefield, visit the cheese shop, pick up a few raisin puffs, and settle in for a plate of turkey and dressing. Thanksgiving dinner is available all year here, with one important exception: Thanksgiving Day itself. Apparently, even the people making Thanksgiving dinner deserve a day off. And really, isn’t Thanksgiving better when someone else does the dishes?
Want to discover more hidden gems in your own backyard? Get your daily dose of travel inspiration from Only In Your State sent straight to your inbox.