undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
New Jersey

Commentary | You Work for Everyone: A Warning to New Jersey’s School Boards

By Eliza Schleifstein,

3 days ago

To the newly elected members of New Jersey’s Boards of Education, and those returning to their seats:

Congratulations. You ran for public office and earned the confidence of voters in your communities. But before settling into your new positions, remember one fundamental principle: You were elected to represent everyone, not just the people who voted for you, agree with you, or happen to be your friends.

Too often, a Board of Education seat becomes a personal platform, a popularity contest, or an opportunity to build alliances and consolidate power. It is a public responsibility that demands transparency, accountability, independent thinking, and respect for the people you serve.

Unfortunately, my town, Randolph Township has provided a case study in what happens when elected officials lose sight of that responsibility.

Randolph: A cautionary tale in public service

Current Randolph Board President Amanda Adams’ tenure – now ending on December 31, 2026 with her unsuccessful bid for re-election – offers important lessons about what public service should not look like.

Emails obtained through an OPRA request revealed Adams’ proposed strategy for dealing with fellow Board member Sheldon Epstein, who repeatedly asked questions and challenged decisions. “I’m thinking that we ignore him as much as we can and offer him minimal responses to his questions in public,” she wrote. She followed with: “My plan is to suffocate him with my silence.”

Think about that. An elected board member was asking questions as part of his oversight responsibilities. Rather than answering them, the proposed strategy was to marginalize and ignore him.

Adams also directed an obscenity at Epstein during a closed session, later apologizing to others in the room for the ensuing public controversy, but not to the colleague she directly targeted and not for what she had actually said.  Adams then seemingly encouraged some of her fellow Board members to make public speeches from the dais criticizing residents who questioned her leadership, and there were other, repeated instances in which legitimate questions were treated as personal attacks.

Residents tried to warn her that she was not acting appropriately as a leader. They came to the podium during public comment. They wrote emails. They asked for one-on-one meetings. They questioned spending and asked for accountability. Each of them offered Adams a chance to listen to the community’s concerns. Too often, the response was the same from Adams: dismiss the concerns, question the motives, attack the messengers.

During the campaign, residents pointed to Adams’ voting record. The response was indignation. Pointing to her votes, Adams and her supporters complained, was cruel and unfair.

Let’s be clear. A voting record is not misinformation. It is not a personal attack. It is a public record, created by the officeholder herself. Anyone who reads it back is simply stating facts.

Elections exist to put an officeholder’s performance under scrutiny. This is not a race for senior class president or homecoming queen. It was never meant to be a popularity contest. It is a judgment on the merits: how you conducted yourself in office, and how you voted. Just ask the dozens of members of Congress who were voted out this month.

If you are proud of your votes, defend them to the people paying the bills. If you are embarrassed by them, don’t blame the people reading the record. Change the record and vote differently the next time.

When voters speak, leadership means listening

Following her election defeat, Adams posted a concession statement on Facebook and later offered her perspective in a TAPinto interview.

In the Facebook statement, Adams wrote, “Not every seat with influence is at the dais.”

It was a remarkable line from someone who, while she held the gavel, acted as though the only voices that mattered were the ones at the dais. Residents who raised concerns at the public microphone were ignored and summarily dismissed. Even a fellow board member asking questions from the dais was to be “suffocated” with silence. Now that she will be on the other side of the dais, Adams appears to have discovered that influence can come from the audience after all. You don’t get to discover the value of the public’s voice only after the public has voted you out and made you one of them.

She also forgot who truly decides whether or not she was on the dais or not.   Missing from every post-election statement she made was a simple thank-you to the Randolph community for the opportunity to serve. Instead, Adams offered more criticism of residents, more finger-pointing, more whining about how “unfair” it was to be held to account, and more explanations of why others were responsible for the outcome.

Public service is a privilege, not an entitlement. When voters give you the gift of public office, and later decide it is time for a change, you say thank you. You don’t point fingers and then try to make yourself into a victim.

An echo chamber is not public support. Silence is not approval. For years, Randolph’s Board leadership had tried to dismiss its critics as a handful of disgruntled, but particularly noisy, residents, while a silent majority supposedly stood behind it 100%. The election finally and deservedly put that story to rest.

More than a thousand more voters chose Epstein than chose Adams. Close to 200 residents commented on social media posts about the election, saying that it was time for a change. Almost none of these residents had ever spoken at a Board meeting, and many had never spoken up publicly before. They are not the usual suspects. They are constituents, and they are done being dismissed.

The absence of residents at the podium does not mean they are satisfied or that they agree with your decisions or support your leadership.

A board is not a posse

There is another lesson from Randolph that every incoming board member should take seriously: School boards are governing bodies, not social clubs, PTOs, volunteer squads, or political alliances.

Board members should collaborate, build working relationships, and strive for consensus when appropriate. But there is a fundamental difference between collaboration and a predetermined voting bloc that operates to protect its members, advance a shared agenda, rubber stamp all of the Superintendent’s recommendations without question or discussion, or shut out dissenting voices.

In Randolph, residents have increasingly raised concerns about what they perceive as an Adams-led inner circle. When a small group of board members consistently aligns itself around the board president and administration, while questions from other members are dismissed, independent oversight suffers.

Every board member has an equal vote and an independent responsibility to the district. No one should be expected to demonstrate loyalty to a board president, superintendent, or group of colleagues in exchange for information, influence, or acceptance.

A board member’s obligation is to students, taxpayers, and the community, not to a posse. Disagreement is not dysfunction. A board where everyone agrees all the time should raise questions about whether members are exercising independent judgment.

And a board that decides which residents are worth hearing, treats questions as attacks, and listens only to those who already agree with it has no business railing against elitism. That behavior is the very definition of elitism.

What public service actually requires

For incoming and returning board members throughout New Jersey, the expectations should be straightforward:

  • Represent everyone. Your constituents include the people who voted against you, criticize you, and challenge your decisions.
  • Demand transparency. Residents deserve meaningful explanations about budgets, contracts, capital projects, and major decisions.
  • Exercise independent judgment. You were elected to provide oversight, not to rubber-stamp the superintendent’s recommendations or follow a voting bloc.
  • Welcome questions. Parents and taxpayers are not adversaries. Their questions are part of public accountability.
  • Take responsibility. When you make a mistake, acknowledge it. When you treat someone poorly, apologize. When voters express dissatisfaction, listen and find out how you can better meet their concerns.

Supporting excellent schools does not mean writing a blank check. Supporting teachers does not mean refusing to scrutinize administrative decisions. And respecting and supporting the superintendent does not mean surrendering the board’s oversight responsibilities. Fiscal accountability and educational excellence go hand in hand.

The Randolph experience should serve as a warning to every school board member in the state. Holding a position of authority does not make you immune to criticism or entitle you to ignore questions and concerns, and being elected does not give you ownership of the institution you serve.

You were elected to serve the public, not to be served by the public. You were elected to make difficult decisions, not avoid difficult questions. And you were elected to represent everyone, not simply those who agree with you.

Start with gratitude. Lead with transparency. Welcome dissent. Reject factionalism. Take responsibility.

You may hold the seat for three years, but the public’s trust is something you have to earn every single day.

Submitted directly by the author; content reflects their own views

The post Commentary | You Work for Everyone: A Warning to New Jersey’s School Boards appeared first on nj21st.

Comments