‘38 years is too long.’ Norwalk woman appeals for answers on eve of sister’s disappearance

Wednesday marks almost four decades since April Grisanti was forced into a car outside a Norwalk bar and never seen again.

Marissa Alter

Jan 31, 2023, 10:36 PM

Updated 488 days ago

Share:

Wednesday marks almost four decades since April Grisanti was forced into a car outside a Norwalk bar and never seen again.
“This is all I have left of my sister,” said Gina Grisanti as she held onto April Grisanti’s wallet. That wallet was one piece of evidence Norwalk police recovered in her abduction and presumed murder 38 years ago.
On the eve of that somber date, News 12 met up with Gina Grisanti where it was found, near an electrical tower on Fillow Street by Steppingstone Road. That location is about half a mile from the former home of the sole suspect in the case, James “Purple” Aaron, who was 33 at the time. April Grisanti had previously been involved with him.
The wallet still had her license, credit cards and birth certificate inside. When police returned it to Gina Grisanti, she found something else—police incident reports from when her sister had called police about Aaron.
“That was really hard to see,” said Gina Grisanti.
One report was from Jan. 26, 1985—five days before April Grisanti disappeared. On Feb. 1, just after midnight, witnesses told police Aaron dragged her into his car outside Anthony’s Bar on Main Street. Aaron was later convicted of kidnapping but wasn't charged with her presumed death because police never found her body.
“My sister's body was dumped like garbage,” Gina Grisanti told News 12. “I just want to bring her home, that's it -38 years is too long.”
Aaron died in 2016, but Gina Grisanti said she believes there are people who know what he did with her sister.
“Please, if you have an ounce of humanity, call me. I don't care what your involvement was, just let me bring her home,” Gina Grisanti pleaded.
Gina Grisanti launched her own investigation a couple years ago and said she's confident her sister's body is still in the area. A GoFundMe effort is raising money to support her personal searches. She said she’s also hoping experts in the field will donate their time and services and help her family get closure after a decadeslong wait.
“I'm angry. I'm angry it's still happening 38 years later,” Gina Grisanti said.
Gina Grisanti can be contacted at 203-838-9009 or 203-505-1200.
April Grisanti’s case remains with the Norwalk Police Department’s Cold Case Unit, which can be reached at 203-854-3111. Anonymous tips can be called in to 203-854-3111 or texted to TIP411 (847411) by typing NORWALKPD followed by the information.


More from News 12
0:28
Police: Suspect wanted for shooting 2 men in North Amityville

Police: Suspect wanted for shooting 2 men in North Amityville

1:42
Sunny afternoon, highs in the 80s Monday on Long Island

Sunny afternoon, highs in the 80s Monday on Long Island

2:06
Police: Maryland man arrested for running on to field at T20 Cricket World Cup

Police: Maryland man arrested for running on to field at T20 Cricket World Cup

1:34
Village of Babylon's Pride Parade draws hundreds for Pride Month celebrations

Village of Babylon's Pride Parade draws hundreds for Pride Month celebrations

0:52
Police: Hempstead man accused of robbing woman, crashing stolen car, injuring 2 people and resisting arrest

Police: Hempstead man accused of robbing woman, crashing stolen car, injuring 2 people and resisting arrest

2:02
Study: Empathy is passed from one generation to the next

Study: Empathy is passed from one generation to the next

2024 Cricket World Cup on Long Island - Special Coverage

2024 Cricket World Cup on Long Island - Special Coverage

1:49
Police: Wyandanch man shot in Jake’s 58 Casino Hotel parking lot

Police: Wyandanch man shot in Jake’s 58 Casino Hotel parking lot

2:48
‘Test match’ at T20 Cricket World Cup goes smoothly; games in Nassau start Monday

‘Test match’ at T20 Cricket World Cup goes smoothly; games in Nassau start Monday

0:23
Police: Man fatally struck by car while crossing street in Brentwood

Police: Man fatally struck by car while crossing street in Brentwood

0:49
'Play For Ryan' Babylon fundraiser benefits son of slain NYPD Detective Jonathan Diller

'Play For Ryan' Babylon fundraiser benefits son of slain NYPD Detective Jonathan Diller

Panthers going back to Stanley Cup Final, top Rangers 2-1 to win East title in 6 games

Panthers going back to Stanley Cup Final, top Rangers 2-1 to win East title in 6 games

1:39
Introducing peanuts to infant’s diet can reduce chances of future allergy, study finds

Introducing peanuts to infant’s diet can reduce chances of future allergy, study finds

1:57
Cricket World Cup set to kick off at Eisenhower Park this weekend

Cricket World Cup set to kick off at Eisenhower Park this weekend

1:25
Businesses near Eisenhower Park hoping to cash in on cricket crowds

Businesses near Eisenhower Park hoping to cash in on cricket crowds

0:24
Police: Man killed in Southern State Parkway crash in North Massapequa

Police: Man killed in Southern State Parkway crash in North Massapequa

1:50
WWII, Korean War veteran laid to rest on LI nearly 60 years after his death

WWII, Korean War veteran laid to rest on LI nearly 60 years after his death

2:16
Nassau police commissioner warns Cricket World Cup attendees not to illegally park in nearby neighborhoods

Nassau police commissioner warns Cricket World Cup attendees not to illegally park in nearby neighborhoods

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

1:32
Father’s Day Gift Ideas: Exclusive Deals – Up to 50% OFF!

Father’s Day Gift Ideas: Exclusive Deals – Up to 50% OFF!